Which of These Two Fighters do You Have Ranked Higher All-Time RIGHT NOW?

[Divine Hammer]

Manny walked away from the fight in 2009, maybe that is why Floyd is more respected by writers/historians/media, some of whom are American but many are not.

Manny was fine, all he needed was a saltwater bath and his shoulder healed. he just lost to a better man.

You said Bradley didn't deserve a top 10 p4p ranking because Manny beat him the 1st fight and then he lost to Provodnikov. Now you are changing. why?

Doesn't matter dude. No matter what Manny has accomplished Floyd beat him and was considered above him well before they fought.

You can keep ****ing the keys on your computer but you are not going to change anything other than the minds of people who think you are a rational adult.

manny didn't walk away u dunce. manny was willing to negotiate the extra testing, but floyd wouldn't budge!! i mean manny was the #1 p4p, superstar, and floyd was fresh back from his "retirement". so how can floyd dictate terms like this?????????? manny drew over 60,000+ to watch him fight clottey! who was the bigger star at the time??? at least manny tried to negotiate.

and when negotiations were heating up floyd "retires" he even told a sick dying kid to his face that he won't fight manny. it was the SICK DYNING KIDS WISH TO SEE HIM FIGHT MANNY IN 2010!!!!!!!!!!!!! and floyd RETIIIIRRREEEDDD!!!!!!!!

and i didn't believe bradley deserved top ten p4p in the first pac fight but he deserved it when he beat marquez who just KO'ED MANNY PACQUIAO #1/2 p4p!!!! and was awarded fighter of the year 2012 by ring magazine and placed at #3 p4p!!!! get a frickin clue seriously. it's easy to understand.

and floyd beat a 36 year old (which is ancient for a guy with manny's style) way past prime manny who had one good arm and only three fights ago suffered a huge humiliating devastating almost career ending KO. floyd's win against manny doesn't prove anything except to say he was far more fresher than manny. that's it. i don't expect u or the biased american "journalists" to understand this.

[Larry the boss]

Numbers dont lie....

[Divine Hammer]

Numbers dont lie....

hahahahaha give me a break. the amount of floyd farts outnumber the rational boxing fans in this forum now. all u punk weirdos have come out in full force since ur hero "beat" a way past prime one good arm manny. get real.

[Marvellous1]

Many Pacquiao refused a deal he was later happy enough to accept. That means he walked from the fight in 2010.

Both great fighters but Mayweather's constant level of excellence at the level he's fought puts him ahead of Manny for me.

[Raonic]

Mayweather ranked higher but they are pretty close. A few ranks between them maybe.

[The Big Dunn]

hahahahaha give me a break. the amount of floyd farts outnumber the rational boxing fans in this forum now. all u punk weirdos have come out in full force since ur hero "beat" a way past prime one good arm manny. get real.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=653826

Sorry dude. Floyd is far ahead of Manny.

[Divine Hammer]

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=653826

Sorry dude. Floyd is far ahead of Manny.

again, how many of them are american writers/historians????? how is it floyd gets to be close to top ten p4p all time when he hasn't even legit beaten ONE prime hof'er???? and chavez sr and pernell whitaker are that high also??? a lot wrong with that list. and if guys like hopkins and roy jones are in there then why not manny and wlad????? manny has accomplished and fought through farr more adversity and hardship than roy, hopkins and floyd. easily. and wlad is one of the greatest heavyweights of all time (and has a huge amount of defenses) yet no mention either???? hahahahaha what a joke list.

this list is too pro-america. too biased.

[The Big Dunn]

again, how many of them are american writers/historians????? how is it floyd gets to be close to top ten p4p all time when he hasn't even legit beaten ONE prime hof'er???? and chavez sr and pernell whitaker are that high also??? a lot wrong with that list. and if guys like hopkins and roy jones are in there then why not manny and wlad????? manny has accomplished and fought through farr more adversity and hardship than roy, hopkins and floyd. easily. and wlad is one of the greatest heavyweights of all time (and has a huge amount of defenses) yet no mention either???? hahahahaha what a joke list.

this list is too pro-america. too biased.

There are non Americans on the list so your complaint makes no sense. Besides, you always argue Manny is more popular than Floyd anyway so it wouldn't matter.

Manny and wlad are not deserving of spots on the list.

there is another poll in the thread that has Floyd as 19th all time. it has different voters.

anyway you cut it, Floyd is better than Manny.

[Beater_of_ass]

I'm not a fan of Floyd or Manny but when Manny's excuse in 2009 was no needles and in 2015 he needed a shot to help him...

Yeah, GTFO with that ****. Even Floyd has more credibility than Manny on top of being higher on the ATG list.

[Divine Hammer]

There are non Americans on the list so your complaint makes no sense. Besides, you always argue Manny is more popular than Floyd anyway so it wouldn't matter.

Manny and wlad are not deserving of spots on the list.

there is another poll in the thread that has Floyd as 19th all time. it has different voters.

anyway you cut it, Floyd is better than Manny.

how is manny and wlad not deserving???? so chavez sr and pernell whitaker accomplished more than manny and beat far better opponents than manny to justify that high????? give me a break. and how is marciano on that list but not wlad?????? where's calzaghe who beat hopkins AND roy????? what is up with this weird list. manny has accomplished MORE than floyd, roy, hopkins, chavez sr, pernell whitaker, marciano, etc.

again this list isn't good. seriously, chavez sr that high???????? even looking at the rest u see foreman above manny???? what sense does that make?

this is pure proganda bias. sure there might be one or two non-americans but the majority is clearly american. just look at that biased list hahahahahahahaha.