Which of These Two Fighters do You Have Ranked Higher All-Time RIGHT NOW?

[IronDanHamza]

manny was declared fighter of the year 3 times (in the same years) by both BWAA and ring, which means he without a doubt deserved fighter of the year in those years no question. floyd on the other hand didn't deserve fighter of the year 2013 and ring recognized this. and floyd didn't deserve fighter of the year in 1998 and BWAA recognized this.

BWAA and ring each have floyd only winning fighter of the year twice. manny without a doubt won it 3 times according to BWAA and ring.

Ok but Floyd still won one of them on 3 seperate occasions.

But continue to move the goalpost to fit your agenda.

[Divine Hammer]

Paquiao is greater. Duran lost to all the guys on the Fab 4 and is still considered greater than most of them.

not to mention pac was way past his prime (further than floyd) when he lost to floyd.

[Divine Hammer]

Ok but Floyd still won one of them on 3 seperate occasions.

But continue to move the goalpost to fit your agenda.

ur just fluffing things to make it look like floyd won it 3 times. when i mean winning it 3 times i mean according to one organization. again, bwaa only declared floyd fighter of the year 2 times same with ring. ur just twisting and fluffing things to make it seem like both organizations have agreed that he deserves fighter of the year 3 times which isn't the case.

if you asked the bwaa if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they'll say NO. if u ask ring magazine if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they will ALSO SAY NO. do you understand now?????

[HanzGruber]

not to mention pac was way past his prime (further than floyd) when he lost to floyd.

That's not what you guys said before May 2nd

[IronDanHamza]

ur just fluffing things to make it look like floyd won it 3 times. when i mean winning it 3 times i mean according to one organization. again, bwaa only declared floyd fighter of the year 2 times same with ring. ur just twisting and fluffing things to make it seem like both organizations have agreed that he deserves fighter of the year 3 times which isn't the case.

if you asked the bwaa if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they'll say NO. if u ask ring magazine if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they will ALSO SAY NO. do you understand now?????

No I'm just stating that if you're including the ring a magazine like you did then Floyd has won Fighter of the year 3 time also.

But now you're saying he has to have won it 3 times with both.

Like I said if you want to move the goalpost to fit your agenda then that's fine.

[Divine Hammer]

That's not what you guys said before May 2nd

i was rooting for manny and i will always root for him. so what???????? i knew manny didn't have it anymore and was far past it, but that doesn't mean i couldn't believe that he could pull off a great performance and have the fire again and show glimpses of a prime pacquiao. mosley showed his old self when he pummeled margarito even though he was completely ancient and shot.

[Divine Hammer]

No I'm just stating that if you're including the ring a magazine like you did then Floyd has won Fighter of the year 3 time also.

But now you're saying he has to have won it 3 times with both.

Like I said if you want to move the goalpost to fit your agenda then that's fine.

floyd hasn't even won it 3 times with either!!!!!!!! hahahahahaha what aren't u getting??????? ur just fluffing and twisting things to make it seem that one organization had him winning 3 times which is not the case.

again if u asked ring if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they will say NOOOOOOOO. if u asked bwaa if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they will also say NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. floyd is only a 2 time fighter of the year according to both organizations.

pac is without a doubt a 3 time fighter of the year because the bwaa and ring have awarded him that. if u asked either organization they will say he is fighter of the year 3 times and they both awarded the same years. there is a complete agreement, but with floyd there are doubts (and there should be because he is a coward fraud). just deal with it.

[IronDanHamza]

floyd hasn't even won it 3 times with either!!!!!!!! hahahahahaha what aren't u getting??????? ur just fluffing and twisting things to make it seem that one organization had him winning 3 times which is not the case.

again if u asked ring if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they will say NOOOOOOOO. if u asked bwaa if floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year they will also say NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. floyd is only a 2 time fighter of the year according to both organizations.

pac is without a doubt a 3 time fighter of the year because the bwaa and ring have awarded him that. if u asked either organization they will say he is fighter of the year 3 times and they both awarded the same years. there is a complete agreement, but with floyd there are doubts (and there should be because he is a coward fraud). just deal with it.

If you ask BWAA if Floyd h's ever won fighter of the year they will say "Twice - 2007 and 2013"

If you ask The Ring if Floyd was ever fighter of the year they will say "Twice - 1998 and 2007"

So 1998, 2007, 2013 Floyd was fighter of the year according to one of them.

But as we've established you've moved the goalpost now and now it's has to be both for all three. Which is fine I expect no less.

[Divine Hammer]

If you ask BWAA if Floyd h's ever won fighter of the year they will say "Twice - 2007 and 2013"

If you ask The Ring if Floyd was ever fighter of the year they will say "Twice - 1998 and 2007"

So 1998, 2007, 2013 Floyd was fighter of the year according to one of them.

But as we've established you've moved the goalpost now and now it's has to be both for all three. Which is fine I expect no less.

floyd wasn't without a doubt fighter of the year 1998 or 2013. bwaa didn't think floyd was fighter of the year 1998, and ring didn't think floyd was fighter of the year 2013. but pacquiao was without a doubt fighter of the year 2006, 2008, and 2009 according to both organizations. there is a complete agreement there is more legitimacy. both organizations recognize manny as a 3 time fighter of the year.

again ur just fluffing things finding loopholes twisting everything to make it seem like floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year. floyd is only a 2 time fighter of the year. only considered a 2 time fighter of the year with the bwaa and ring and that's how he will be remembered. u and the rest of the farts need to deal with that.

[Nay_Sayer]

If the Triple Duck wins the *legitimate* 160lb title - and Pacroid goes up to middleweight and beats Bumlovkin for it - MAYBE then you'd have an argument for ranking him even with or higher than Mayweather. MAYBE...