Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Pound-for-Pound Update

[bigjavi973]

1. Mayweather

2. Klitschko

3. Ward

4. Gonzalez

5. Rigondeaux

6. Pacquiao

7. Froch

8. Kovalev

9. Golovkin

10. Garcia

if you take out ward due to inactivity would your list just each move up one who'll be the new number "10" on your list.

[IMDAZED]

if you take out ward due to inactivity would your list just each move up one who'll be the new number "10" on your list.

The guy in your avi

[bigjavi973]

The guy in your avi

[BrometheusBob.]

The Op's list is the first I have see with Estrada on it - so much credit for that.
1/ Gonzalez
2/ Mayweather
3/ Rigo
4/ Inoue
5/ Ward
6/ Estrada
7/ Uchiyama
8/ Nietes
9/ Crawford
10/ GGG

See my post above for reasoning.

Gonzalez > Mayweather is beyond buggin.

No Wlad is also ridiculous.

lol basically little of this list I can agree with.

[BrometheusBob.]

What kind of bullshit is this???

Thurman/Brook > Garcia p4p???

I'd without a doubt have put Garcia above them if you asked me after he beat Matthysse. Right now spot #10 for me is a toss up, and I wouldn't necessarily think it's ridiculous to put Garcia there given he has wins against significant people.

That being said I stand by Crawford > Garcia. He's on a streak of very strong wins against pretty solid competition and is without a doubt going to be a factor at 140 for some time (or until he moves up, if ever).

[RED REP]

1) Mayweather jr

Gonzalez #1 is lol.

[St. Johns Gent]

Uchiyama, Yamanaka and Inoue should all be ahead of Crawford without a doubt.

i really wish those japanese fighters were televised here in the states

[HEND]

#3 Kovalev
#5 Golovkin

These two are really climbing in almost all of the lists now.

Idk why though... Did I miss Golovkin beating an elite opponent or what? Kovalev is definitely in the top 10 but that #3 seems like a stretch.

[Marcov]

Manny was dropped too far.

[deanrw]

Someone named something like sim_shandi sent me their P4P list to post , as they were having trouble loading the page

1: Carl Froch
2: Gennady Golovkin
3: Wladamir Klitschko
4: Sergey Kovalev
5: George Groves
6: Carl Frampton
7: Scott Quigg
8: Vasily Lomachenko
9: David Lemieux
10: Denis Lebedev