Comments Thread For: BoxingScene.com's Pound-for-Pound Update

[aboutfkntime]

I dont take P4P lists seriously.....

1) they are entirely subjective

2) everybody uses different qualifying criteria

3) most " P4P " lists, are actually " my favorite fighter " lists

4) they are completely theoretical, therefore irrelevant

But yea, sometimes fun to debate.

I'm not trying to be picky, just proving a point..... and, Roldie is a rockstar.....

But.....

If the qualifying criteria is accomplishments, then why are Kovalev/GGG rated ahead of Marquez/Ward/Pacquiao, and even Bradley.....

And if the qualifying criteria is, the winner in a potential matchup with all things being equal..... why is Rigo behind Kovalev, Pacquiao behind Golovkin, etc.....

I'm a picky cvnt, I know

Determining the criteria, is the key.

[Showtime..]

Still tired of people saying that Floyd utterly outclassed Pacquiao when that clearly isn't true, but whatever.
Floyd is clear #1 atm.
Roman better knock Segura out in 2 rounds or I'm dropping him, shoulda fought Estrada.
Wlad at #3; fight Fury or he drops.
Pacquiao at #4.
Kovalev #5.
GGG#6
Rigo #7
Canelo #8
Crawford #9
Estrada #10.

[GRIP STACCIN]

you literally have kovalev as #3, and ggg and pac still on ur list,,like oh wow smfh

take a walk man u dont knw boxing

[GRIP STACCIN]

theres no way cryquiao should be top 5 at all,,no way at all....i have him mabe #8 or 9,,

GGG should not be on ur list especially not if ur not gonna even considerg having crawford on there,,i mean wtf

[Mike D]

what kind of bull crap list is this?? blasphemy! the entire list! Crawford is rated higher than Danny but Crawford has one belt in the 140, GGG fights nothing but FNF fighters hell Santa Cruz has beaten way better opposition than triple fraud, Bradley??? seriously, and Chocolatito over Estrada, who has faced the tougher opposition hands down and is the only unified champ in that division??? and to include the fraud with the shoulder injury is a joke, whoever the writer is needs to get off the hype HBO purposely creates by orchestrating mismatches like Canelo vs Churchland (Church=Kirk=Circe=sorceress that'll turn you into a pig with power of illusion and devour your soul just like church), GGG vs Boxcino, Chocolate vs guy with a broken face years ago

1. Floyd TBE
2. Klitschko Domination
3. Rigo untouchable
4. Danny lineal, undisputed since 2012
5. Kovalev 3 belts in that weight
6. Estrada cleaned out that division
7. Loma Skills beyond words
8. Crawford handily beaten good fighters
9. Chocolatito
10. Andy Lee fights the best at 160, fights all the monsters, not some 6 ko boxcino champ

You should be humanely euthanized for putting Danny Garcia at 4.

[Ringlife]

That's one bull s##t list, Gonzalez at number 2 get it together....

[Yaconcha]

theres no way cryquiao should be top 5 at all,,no way at all....i have him mabe #8 or 9,,

GGG should not be on ur list especially not if ur not gonna even considerg having crawford on there,,i mean wtf

at last! somebody with a brain!
A fackin MEN to this fellah. i quite agree but, to leave the great marquez out is too early especially after the pac8itch take out. should be (or have been) placed in top three anyway.