The Greatest Fighter of Our Era?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

To Pac's credit, he's fought everyone. And he's revenged some losses.

Floyd "retired" and avoided prime Cotto, Margarito, Williams.

I still think Floyd is the best of the era though.

who's Floyd's best win?

[IMDAZED]

who's Floyd's best win?

Probably Diego Corrales. Tough one.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Probably Diego Corrales. Tough one.

that's why its hard to build the argument for Floyd

[Joe Beamish]

who's Floyd's best win?

Best wins: Corrales, ODLH, total domination of Alvarez, KO Hatton.

Not exactly on par with SRL's best wins, but still good when combined with no losses

[The Big Dunn]

who's Floyd's best win?

don't losses and draws count against a fighter as much as "best win" counts toward a fighter's assessment of greatest of our generation?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Best wins: Corrales, ODLH, total domination of Alvarez, KO Hatton.

Not exactly on par with SRL's best wins, but still good when combined with no losses

yea...that doesn't really scream 'greatest of our generation'

[Left Hook Tua]

Probably Diego Corrales. Tough one.

it has to be chico.

chico was a beast.

super big for his division with power. like a 130 thomas hearns.

the way floyd picked him apart and destroyed him was amazing.

[bojangles1987]

115-113...dominance



and they say PAC fans are ******

And "lost" to Bradley. Some people love to pretend Pac actually lost that fight.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

don't losses and draws count against a fighter as much as "best win" counts toward a fighter's assessment of greatness?

oh Ali lost a couple times...that nullifies all his wins against Foreman, Frazier, Norton etc


Dunn, please STFU

[IMDAZED]

that's why its hard to build the argument for Floyd

Nah, I disagree with that entirely. He's got a slew of excellent wins. You don't need to beat a prime HOF to qualify. Julio Cesar Chavez Sr. never did and he is a true ATG. It's a lot more than just that.