Should Gennady Golovkin be in the top 10 P4P?

[-Antonio-]

Let's see Floyd is 5 foot 8 GGG is 5 foot 9 GGG has 13 pounds and 1 inch on him how is that a huge difference Ward is 6 foot 1 to GGG 5 foot 9

I like how you take two inches of height away from GGG and add an inch to Ward.

[therealpugilist]

Lol Dirrell's pedigree. He's done at the top level. Froch isn't doing anything with GGG, he won't even get in the ring with him.

Compare GGG level of comp froch
Not even close froch is proven and fought the best in a deep division not a mediocre one like 160 not much depth

Pedigree in the ams and pros

He has fought fighters of different styles and classes...Carl froch and Abraham are much better than rubio, Macklin, and geale he also beat Stevens first... He has world class experience like GGG in the am pros...you know pedigree lol

[El-blanco]

Real boxing fans: yes

Black supremacists: no

[BigZigga]

He's getting close if he's not already there

[Phenom]

nope he needs a good name on his resume I seen prospects with better resumes

[DannYankee]

The hypetrain side of my brain says yes the merit measuring side of my brain says no. Let merit win out the day this time.

[b00g13man]

I haven't given much thought to it, but I don't think I'd have a problem having him around 9 or 10. It has to be stated that his resume is absolutely woeful, and I'd never normally consider someone with such a resume in the top 10.

It also has to be stated that GGG fanboys are making it really hard to root for him. It's ridiculous.

[Daddy T]

P4P is supposed to be about who you think RIGHT now would win if everybody was the same weight.

People seemed to have lost track of that these days and think it is just a compare boxrec resume competition.

No way are there ten guys out there that would be backed to beat GGG if you shrunk or increased them to 160.

(This is why Rigo even more so than GGG should be way, way, way up the p4p lists btw)

[junior gong]

P4P is supposed to be about who you think RIGHT now would win if everybody was the same weight.

People seemed to have lost track of that these days and think it is just a compare boxrec resume competition.

No way are there ten guys out there that would be backed to beat GGG if you shrunk or increased them to 160.

(This is why Rigo even more so than GGG should be way, way, way up the p4p lists btw)

This is really all that needs to be said.

[junior gong]

Real boxing fans: yes

Black supremacists: no

Thats so true of this forum.