Should Gennady Golovkin be in the top 10 P4P?

[therealpugilist]

I'll give you a minute red-bar.

Garcia himself is only a puncher, explain what other skills he possesses, because he was made to look like garbage against Herrera, Judah and Khan - especially before you guessed it landed his hook.

I'LL GIVE YOU a sec know nothing about boxing

if ggg fought some decent comp world class competition you will see what happens

Garcia is a counterpuncher....Wins over Holt, morales Khan, Matthyssee, Judah, Herrera, is a lot better than proska, macklin and Rubio


Garcia is a world champion....ggg holds a trinket

big difference

[therealpugilist]

The problem is everybody saw Garcia lose to a fringe contender just this year. That'll drop you p4p

still doesn't take away what he has done which is a lot more than ggg is a pitiful weight class

[Chiboxing123]

golovkin in over danny Garcia is a joke....Garcia has more fights, actually is a lineal world champion beat other title holders, and has made defenses

GGG is just another contender in his division...my god yall overrate punchers and aggressive guys on this NSB

Like I said 3G is special. He's on a different level than you're Garcia, broners, porters and Thurman's. And u can tell. Just LOOK. Put him in ure prime manny PAC,prime Tito,prime de la hoya territory cause that's what we are witnessing. You will see once these guy step up the resume will come after.

[HeroBando]

still doesn't take away what he has done which is a lot more than ggg is a pitiful weight class

No doubt he has a better resume, but you lose to a fringe contender and you drop p4p. Thems the rules, sorry pal

[therealpugilist]

No doubt he has a better resume, but you lose to a fringe contender and you drop p4p. Thems the rules, sorry pal

Herrera is a top junior welterweight and no one has looked good fighting him

IF them the rules, the rules also state you have to beat p4p opposition or near it to rise up the rankings as well

the guy beats Rubio and now he is supposed to be top ten p4p when there are guys who actually fought and beat stiff competition and yall don't have them in the convo

put GGG in with an elite fighters or near p4p guys between 154-168 and he beats 2 then we have a real discussion(Ward, Froch, Cotto, Kessler, Andrade, Canelo, etc) ....as of now in comparison to other guys considered his resume is garbage...he has not beat ONE elite p4p type fighter and you guys are arguing he is top ten?
he has been

Most of you guys don't even know who roman gonzalez and Francisco Estrada are but they have defeated better opposition and have proven more than passed an eye test...they beat world class guys in the ring

[MRCHOKEaMF]

He's being considered because he's ko'd almost everyone he's faced...So I guess he goes on the list when Wilder gets on cause he's ko'd EVERYONE he's faced. RIGHT. How can he be on the list for ko's and thats it, and someone who's ko'd everyone he's faced and not be on it. Kos are the only reason this guy has fans. Fighting some comp is out the window, the next thing in boxing is fighting tomato cans, cause now beating rubio makes you top ten p4p.

[HeroBando]

Herrera is a top junior welterweight and no one has looked good fighting him

IF them the rules, the rules also state you have to beat p4p opposition or near it to rise up the rankings as well

the guy beats Rubio and now he is supposed to be top ten p4p when there are guys who actually fought and beat stiff competition and yall don't have them in the convo

put GGG in with an elite fighters or near p4p guys between 154-168 and he beats 2 then we have a real discussion(Ward, Froch, Cotto, Kessler, Andrade, Canelo, etc) ....as of now in comparison to other guys considered his resume is garbage...he has not beat ONE elite p4p type fighter and you guys are arguing he is top ten?
he has been

Most of you guys don't even know who roman gonzalez and Francisco Estrada are but they have defeated better opposition and have proven more than passed an eye test...they beat world class guys in the ring

Herrera really wasnt a top contender. He convincingly lost to Alvarado and Mayfield not long ago. You cant be p4p losing to him recently

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

GGG at welterweight doesn't sound healthy.

[Accountoffline]

Danny Jacobs
Peter Quillin
Demetrius Andrade
Andre Dirrell
Andre Ward

Them 5 guys right there I consider better then GGG and all have a better resume and they all in range where he can fight em

Top 10 p4p my ass

I wonder what them 5 have in common?

Black supremacist goin in hard yo!

[KillaMane26]

Danny Jacobs
Peter Quillin
Demetrius Andrade
Andre Dirrell
Andre Ward

Them 5 guys right there I consider better then GGG and all have a better resume and they all in range where he can fight em

Top 10 p4p my ass

LMFAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He would KO all of them outside of Ward ( maybe andre)