Should Gennady Golovkin be in the top 10 P4P?

[therealpugilist]

Hell no....he hasn't beat anyone near the p4p rankings so he damn sure don't belong

people are so wrapped up with what he could do than what he actually has, at this point he is nothing more than a top contender in his weight class.




Mayweather, Pacquaio, Chocolatito, Marquez, Danny Garcia, Ward, Rigondeaux, Hopkins, Bradley, Klitschko, Froch, Canelo, Juan Fransico Estrada are all ahead of him

although they are not on hot streaks, Nonito and Khan have far deeper resumes and have fought far superior opposition.

if you got him top 10 p4p you are a definite fan boy because you actually have to beat good p4p or near p4p fighters to earn the distinction....anyone can look dominant in a weak weight class.

[therealpugilist]

on this forum just like other places where most the fans are casual fans...punchers are highly overrated and pure boxers are underrated and deemed boring...go figure

golovkin hasn't faced anyone to even be in the conversation

[gabrielmolilulu]

Yes, he should be on the ranking. He doesn't have a great resume yet, but is a solid and exciting undefeated Middleweight champion with a historical record of KO's.

Floyd
Pac
Ward
W.Klitschko
R.Gonzalez
Rigo
Cotto
Froch
Golovkin
JMM

[therealpugilist]

Yes, he should be on the ranking. He doesn't have a great resume yet, but is a solid and exciting undefeated Middleweight champion with a historical record of KO's.

Floyd
Pac
Ward
W.Klitschko
R.Gonzalez
Rigo
Cotto
Froch
Golovkin
JMM

what about Francisco Estrada, Bradley, marquez, danny Garcia has fewer fights and far better comp and is a real world champion...GGG is no where near top ten...he passes the eye test but what he has done in the ring leaves much to be desired

Khan and Nonito may have loses but you cant question their opposition or accomplishments

[artfuL_]

Ward probably should be removed from most lists by now. He's not relevant. Not sure why anyone talks about him tbh

Most lists usually allow a maximum of one years inactivity. If Ward does not nail a fight within a month he will be removed most likely.

[Chiboxing123]

Yes, he should be on the ranking. He doesn't have a great resume yet, but is a solid and exciting undefeated Middleweight champion with a historical record of KO's.

Floyd
Pac
Ward
W.Klitschko
R.Gonzalez
Rigo
Cotto
Froch
Golovkin
JMM

U gotta a good list. Seems about right I agree with all ten names in ure list just a little different placement

[therealpugilist]

U gotta a good list. Seems about right I agree with all ten names in ure list just a little different placement

golovkin in over danny Garcia is a joke....Garcia has more fights, actually is a lineal world champion beat other title holders, and has made defenses

GGG is just another contender in his division...my god yall overrate punchers and aggressive guys on this NSB

[artfuL_]

golovkin in over danny Garcia is a joke....Garcia has more fights, actually is a lineal world champion beat other title holders, and has made defenses

GGG is just another contender in his division...my god yall overrate punchers and aggressive guys on this NSB

I'll give you a minute red-bar.

Garcia himself is only a puncher, explain what other skills he possesses, because he was made to look like garbage against Herrera, Judah and Khan - especially before you guessed it landed his hook.

[PACnPBFsuck]

He wasn't top 10 before Rubio, why would he be top 10 after him.

[HeroBando]

golovkin in over danny Garcia is a joke....Garcia has more fights, actually is a lineal world champion beat other title holders, and has made defenses

GGG is just another contender in his division...my god yall overrate punchers and aggressive guys on this NSB

The problem is everybody saw Garcia lose to a fringe contender just this year. That'll drop you p4p