Should Gennady Golovkin be in the top 10 P4P?

[The Hammer]

LMFAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He would KO all of them outside of Ward ( maybe andre)

..

[Foreign Soil]

I'm laughing so hard at how bad GGG has the forum critics in a panic. It's like the scattering of ants.

[Luilun]

Come on man I am no Floyd fan but Floyd is a little guy so GGG could go up and fight Ward

And then he if beats Ward then he takes his place in the top ten

But don't tell me GGG is a small middleweight right?

Real men go up in weight and fight someone bigger not going down in weight to fight someone smaller

Let's see Floyd is 5 foot 8 GGG is 5 foot 9 GGG has 13 pounds and 1 inch on him how is that a huge difference Ward is 6 foot 1 to GGG 5 foot 9

[$tate of Mind]

Nope, he hasn't beaten anybody. He has top 10 ability but not top 10 credentials. This question just illustrates the weakness of the current state of boxing.

[therealpugilist]

It illustrates the lack of elite p4p types in his weight class is more like it....154 is loaded n 168 is not too far behind.

I'd pick ward and froch to beat him if he moved up. Andre Dirrell too with his style, natural ability length n pedigree

[HeroBando]

It illustrates the lack of elite p4p types in his weight class is more like it....154 is loaded n 168 is not too far behind.

I'd pick ward and froch to beat him if he moved up. Andre Dirrell too with his style, natural ability length n pedigree

Dirrell couldn't even make separation in a 3 rounder with headgear and big gloves. He'd be looking for Dr Shaw Hi by midway point.

It's too bad p4p Sergio found GGG too much risk vs reward before his knees gave out, he would have gotten it bad with those hands to his waist.

[Foreign Soil]

Lol Dirrell's pedigree. He's done at the top level. Froch isn't doing anything with GGG, he won't even get in the ring with him.

[Yogi007]

A lot of people said yes, but I said no. I really like Golovkin and he is definitely an exciting fighter. The reason I say no, is because he hasn't fought anyone. He maybe, but it is hard for me to say yes, until he fights someone who is worthy of putting him in the top p4p.

[Francis M.]

When the only fighter people can find to Beat GGG is the P4P #2 fighter WARD, who is a division higher than GGG. Then it's fair to say that 3G is p4p top 10.

[-Antonio-]

Geale (Ring #2)
Rubio (Ring #7)
Proksa (was Ring #9 at the time)
Stevens (was top ten at the time he fought GGG)
Macklin (was top ten at the time he fought GGG)
Adama (was close to top ten)

He destroyed them all impressively, without needing to resort to weak tactics like running, pitty-patting, or clamping the opponents' arms.

I don't know if GG is top ten right now. I don't really feel like making a list at the moment. But he has yet to beat a B level fighter. His best win is Geale, who is a "euro bum".