Most Overrated Boxers Of All Time?

[BOXEO _]

I'm not beating my chest about anything. Many here are saying he is so overrated. I am just saying Top 12 best fighter isn't and can't be so overrated.

They're not rating him Top 12 of all time, they're rating him top 12 of the modern era.

[BOXEO _]

What does this have to do with the topic? Lol at insecure Mayweather fans. One thing they have in common is insecurity. The man anointed himself TBE and gets branded on everything he and his posse wears and his fans post on here comparing him to Pacman at every opportunity.

[DeadLikeMe]

Do you read? Thread is titled most overrated boxer...not an invitation for who is better between Pacman and Mayweather. If you and Mayweather feel he is TBE he is obviously overrated since he is #12 on that list you beating your chest about.

Let me ask you this, is Manny ranked properly on that list in your opinion?

[HeGotPacProblem]

Let me ask you this, is Manny ranked properly on that list in your opinion?

I don't know everyone in that list so i dont know about #36 but Floyd should be ranked higher than Pacman if that's your real question. But let's get real people remember the top 5, not what order your are from #5 thru 50. They are ATGS period.

[BoxingIsGreat]

They're not rating him Top 12 of all time, they're rating him top 12 of the modern era.

That's exactly what they are doing. Look at the guys above him. SRR is the ATG, according to some, no? All the ATG are on this list.

[HeGotPacProblem]

That's exactly what they are doing. Look at the guys above him. SRR is the ATG, according to some, no? All the ATG are on this list.

It's after ww2.

[Jay Volcano]

Lennox Lewis

[BoxingIsGreat]

It's after ww2.

OK, then, Mr. Historian, who would you put above those guys before WWII? Looking forward to your answer.

Also, in my opinion, Duran and Chavez are way, way too high on that list.

[DeadLikeMe]

According to McGrain the criteria was every fighter who fought any portion of their career during or after WWII. Not necessarily their best body of work, but some portion had to of fallen into the Modern Era.

[HeGotPacProblem]

OK, then, Mr. Historian, who would you put above those guys before WWII? Looking forward to your answer.

Also, in my opinion, Duran and Chavez are way, way too high on that list.

I never called myself a historian. The list is was selected by the boxing gurus and historians.