Who has faced better competition? Broner or Golovkin?

[The Hammer]

GGG has wins over Dirrell, Bute, Lee, Macklin, Stevens, etc.

Broner has lost to Maidana, and robbed the much smaller Ponce de Leon. He's never beaten a good prime fighter.

[Xi_]

I am not a GGG-tard, the problem with you is you spin the stuff I say or you can't read. You said Broner is fighting top 10 guys. I said fighting a top 10 guy means **** when your division isn't deep then I gave the example that supported how misleading top 10 can be by saying GGG beat two top 10 guys (Macklin and Stevens) and how bad they were. Yet you spin it to make it seem like I'm saying how good his opposition is.

Adama is not good but your bringing up Golovkins last fight, when Broner fought a guy who is even worse. You say Broners was a confidence builder but he fought on HBO PPV where Golovkin fought a stay busy out of the country not even on American television. Who exactly did you want him to fight in those circumstances?

Also Demarco sucks, I don't get why this guy is all of a sudden getting so much praise on this thread

Adama is a cab driver....the fact that GGG fought him is a disgrace, so much so that hbo said **** you we're not televising that BS! he could have went up in weight or down in weight and fought better opposition. you said malinaggi wasn't good but isn't that the same guy everyone is giving porter credit for beating? molina has fought tougher guys than adama.....GGG resume is not better than broner's and i'm not even sold on him being the better overall fighter.

[Larry the boss]

GGG has wins over Dirrell, Bute, Lee, Macklin, Stevens, etc.

Broner has lost to Maidana, and robbed the much smaller Ponce de Leon. He's never beaten a good prime fighter.

He did not face Bute, nor Dirrell in the pro's, damn can we please just keep it real?

[Xi_]

I see your logic but Golovkin is a beast cause he goes for the kill. He has a high KO percentage and has KO'd the majority of his last 10 opponents.

Broner on the other hand, talks so much game but rarely produces. He talks as if he's the next Mayweather and such, which he's not. That is why people call him a hype job as well as other things.

He hasn't really fought that much good comp(Broner). People are basing it off Maidana kicking his ass.

GGG is a hypejob based on what fans believe......most people don't think broner is the next mayweather. they think he is a clown, having said that he's still got the better resume and face better fighters than GGG.

[The Hammer]

He did not face Bute, nor Dirrell in the pro's, damn can we please just keep it real?

Before he turned pro, Golovkin faced and beat all the top amateurs. He won several Gold medals, including one at light welterweight in 2000, and Olympic Silver at middleweight in 2004.

Before he turned pro, Broner was beating up and robbing old ladies.

[Fetta]

Before he turned pro, Golovkin faced and beat all the top amateurs. He won several Gold medals, including one at light welterweight in 2000, and Olympic Silver at middleweight in 2004.

Before he turned pro, Broner was beating up and robbing old ladies.

Shimming has several Gold medals

Wilder has a bronze medal and is undefeated with a 100% KO ratio

[Larry the boss]

Before he turned pro, Golovkin faced and beat all the top amateurs. He won several Gold medals, including one at light welterweight in 2000, and Olympic Silver at middleweight in 2004.

Before he turned pro, Broner was beating up and robbing old ladies.

When you get done with all that we are talking professional wins.. who has Golovkin beaten as a pro?? how many current world champions?

[IronDanHamza]

i'm not contesting that broner has a better resume but it's not that much like you claimed. what he has over golovkin was his wins against demarco and malignaggi that's it. losing to maidana diminished his resume whether you like it or not.

How does a loss, to a top fighter no less, "diminish" your resume?

I thought Loss's were ok. Now one loss dimishes a fighters resume?

[Larry the boss]

Shimming has several Gold medals

Wilder has a bronze medal and is undefeated with a 100% KO ratio

Yep according to Tunney they are great fighters

[tyshun30]

Broner it is not even close