It's Pretty Well Accepted Maidana Won Rds 8, 12

[-PBP-]

After rewatching the bout I can CLEARLY give Maidana 1,5 and 8. If I am in an overly generous mood I'll give him 12. No more than that. On first watch I thought he won 4 of the first 5 rounds. Negative. He only won 3 MAYBE 4 rounds. Reminds me of the Cotto bout.

Those are his only clear indisputable rounds. Any other round that somebody gives to Maidana is up for debate.

That's why even the 117-111 card wasn't that crazy. The judge just gave Floyd the close rounds the same way the judge that had it 114-114 gave Maidana the close rounds.

[Beercules]

By handled do you mean losing 8 to 9 rounds? Your bias is showing, and it isn't pretty.

LOL my bias? Jesus Christ. Maidana dictated the pace of the fight, was more active and landed more punches.

And don't give me the ShoStats; Floyd fans said they didn't matter in the Castillo 1 fight so why should they matter now 44-1-1

[-DSG-]

2,4 and 6 Mayweather won clearly. Arguably 3 (Hardest round to score).

Isn't round 4 the round mayweather got cut in? Could have swore he ran and held that round.

[Doctor_Tenma]

After rewatching the bout I can CLEARLY give Maidana 1,5 and 8. If I am in an overly generous mood I'll give him 12. No more than that. On first watch I thought he won 4 of the first 5 rounds. Negative. He only won 3 MAYBE 4 rounds. Reminds me of the Cotto bout.

Same as me, still gave him the 3rd even though that can easily go to Mayweather. 12 is still a stretch because every clean punch that landed in that round, as little as it was, came from Mayweather. Oi Skills, live that performance had me worried but upon rewatching it Mayweather was defensively sharp I expect his offense to click better in a rematch. Other than his bitter fans I'm gonna enjoy the rematch.

[hugh grant]

People picking at straws making claims of who won what rounds, which shows just how hard it is to judge a fight, because everyone sees things differently. YOu can almost make the rules up yourself.

Khan and Maidana was pretty close, and I don't think Maidana disputed the decision. FLoyd and Maidana, Maidana thinks he beat Floyd pretty handily.

I don't think Maidana is dishonest, I wish I could say the same for Floyd.

[Resilient]

By handled do you mean losing 8 to 9 rounds? Your bias is showing, and it isn't pretty.

This is typical Floydiot tactics, always try to revise history. Just like ODLH vs Floyd wasn't close

[Doctor_Tenma]

Isn't round 4 the round mayweather got cut in? Could have swore he ran and held that round.

It is, which is the comical part of it all and still one of Mayweather's clearest rounds.

[-PBP-]

People picking at straws making claims of who won what rounds, which shows just how hard it is to judge a fight, because everyone sees things differently. YOu can almost make the rules up yourself.

Khan and Maidana was pretty close, and I don't think Maidana disputed the decision. FLoyd and Maidana, Maidana thinks he beat Floyd pretty handily.

I don't think Maidana is dishonest, I wish I could say the same for Floyd.

Yeah but out of 100 something press scores 8% scored it for Maidana. This was not a "could of gone either way" fight. People are just stretching it and watching it 100 times to try and see if they can justify scoring more rounds for Maidana at this point.

[Da Machine]

Those are his only clear indisputable rounds. Any other round that somebody gives to Maidana is up for debate.

That's why even the 117-111 card wasn't that crazy. The judge just gave Floyd the close rounds the same way the judge that had it 114-114 gave Maidana the close rounds.

You talk as if all close rds go to Mayweather that's non sense. Mayweather only had 4 clear rds himself.

[Da Machine]

It is, which is the comical part of it all and still one of Mayweather's clearest rounds.

He didn't win rd 4. Not at all.