Comments Thread For: De La Hoya Slams Mayweather: He Should Be 43-3!

[Bardock]

115-113 or even 114 all for either man would've been fine...you've got people on here claiming a clear sweep of any close round towards mayweather. It's this ridiculous pre-conceived notion that if it's an even round or even remotely close it should go to mayweather regardless if he was outlanded in those rounds or not. People also seem keen to refuse to score punches that land when against the ropes.

school these kids bro

[QballLobo]

And he should have been DQ'd against Judah and Ortiz.
Everyone knows that Floyd is actually a 5 loss fighter...

[megas30]

Maidana gave a spirited performance, and with that, deserves a second big pay day. Bring on the rematch or him against Pac. Give him someone where he can get a another huge payday. This man deserves it. This is one of the rare time I heard a fighter say I will give it my all and gone ahead and do just that. Props to Maidana. Floyd looked a little off, maybe it was due to Maidana or something else, I won't speculate. Maidana did bring it. Floyd is just that good that having close fight equals a lost for him.

[MrP4P]

I think he lost to Castillo in their first fight and last night's fight was a draw, because while it is true that Mayweather landed the cleaner face shots, he was pillow-fisted compared to Maidana, who really rocked Floyd when he was able to catch him clean, specially on the ropes. Just look at Maidana's and Floyd's faces after the fight: Maidana looked like he didn't even come to fight, while Mayweather did show signs of being hit hard a few times. Also Maidana was the aggressor all night and that's a point in his favor, they both threw cheap shots when they could, but AS USUAL, Mayweather initiated the clinches 99% of the time. He did his usual excessive clinching every time he was in danger of being hit hard by Maidana and, as usual, the referee protected him, never even warned him about his blatant clinching, which deserved deduction of points if judges were fair and not protective of the big $$$ boxing names.

Most boxing experts, even many Americans, agree that he lost to Castillo in their first fight. Compubox numbers overwhelmingly favor Castillo, both in quantity and accuracy percentage. Castillo was the champ and the aggressor during all their fight. So Floyd should really be 44-1-1 and if he had fought Pacquiao at his best, a few years ago, and Marquez in his natural weight division at that time (lightweight not a blown-up welterweight), then he would be 44-3-1.

I saw your post as being credible and honest until you made assumptions that Pacquiao and Marquez would beat him. Marquez had said (many times) that no rematch was needed with Floyd because it was just a bad style matchup for him and it wouldnt matter what weight class it was, so it seems you have more faith in Marquez than he has in himself.

[hillbilly]

He thinks he beat Floyd? You know what....I won't even use a ******* joke here. It's WAY too easy.

8-4 mayweather in the de la hoya fight and 7-5 last night. The only real loss floyd had was castillo 1, which he decisively erased in the second fight.

[MrP4P]

Ummm this thread is about last nights fight, the castillo fight and the de la hoya fight as oscar claims floyd lost to all three hence why we are talkin about Castillo 1

Um my post was directed at him, not you since you clearly dont understand.. Im basically asking him what does last night have to do with him not defending the first Castillo fight anymore as he stated.

[MrP4P]

8-4 mayweather in the de la hoya fight and 7-5 last night. The only real loss floyd had was castillo 1, which he decisively erased in the second fight.

Thats fair. I was young when I saw that fight but I believed it could have gone either way. The only people who are obsessed with Mayweathers 0 is his haters which is ironic. I would and could accept a Mayweather loss at any point of his career and be perfectly fine with it as a fan of his.

[megadeth]

Oscar meant 44-2...but he was old vs floy and still did ok...

Well, whose fault was that? Floyd wanted to fight Oscar years before Oscar FINALLY accepted his challenge.

[Dice]

Um my post was directed at him, not you since you clearly dont understand.. Im basically asking him what does last night have to do with him not defending the first Castillo fight anymore as he stated.

Umm you clearly need to understand that you put me in my place and that I dont have a credible comeback

[285Kid]

What's about the Judah fight when his dad when in the ring , that a DQ win for Judah