Comments Thread For: De La Hoya Slams Mayweather: He Should Be 43-3!

[turnedup]

The only way to win a fight without a knockdown is to win 7 rounds.. is it really crazy for you to accept a judge gave him an 8th round from one of the first 6 rounds that were

As I said, I am not mad at the outcome just at the ludicrous scoring taking place amongst fans here. 117-111 is a flat out disgrace, flatly put. I would love for anyone here to explain to me how you can score any 8 or 9 rounds for Floyd. I didn't bet on either man, didn't care who won. Am not mad at the outcome but seriously can't fathom how in the hell anyone can score 8 or even 9 rounds in that type of fight for either man. Saying Maidana only won 3 or 4 rounds is flat out hypocrisy. Considering he was the ring general in this fight counts plenty. He took an amazing boxers best abilities away from him, that counts for a lot and also all these people refusing to score the body punches that did land.

[MrP4P]

I agree ODLH won his fight and this Maidana fight was a draw and could easily make an argument he won the first 6 and round 8, and omg the commentators on boxnation were all wearing Floyd tinted spectacles, Maidand would land 10 punches and then Floyd would land one and it was Floyd is dominating the round ? wtf

You thought DLH won? LOL thats all I read but I wont down you too much because its your honest opinion(I think) I personally saw that fight 7-5 and nothing more for Floyd. That was one of Floyds closest fights.

[turnedup]

No, do you not get the convo me and him were having? we were discussing two specific rounds where Maidana outlanded Floyd by 1 or 2 punches... thats all.

Well isn't the point to outland your opponent? Doesn't that determine the winner of a fight..skip the discussion you are having with him..i'm asking an honest question here because i'm trying to really understand how people scored this fight.

[turnedup]

Fk it the outcome happened, rematch or not it was a good fight. People will have their biases and score fights the way that suits them best. It was the closest fight i've seen in a very very long time. Hats off to both men..time to go get crunk..PEACEEEEEEE

[MrP4P]

As I said, I am not mad at the outcome just at the ludicrous scoring taking place amongst fans here. 117-111 is a flat out disgrace, flatly put. I would love for anyone here to explain to me how you can score any 8 or 9 rounds for Floyd. I didn't bet on either man, didn't care who won. Am not mad at the outcome but seriously can't fathom how in the hell anyone can score 8 or even 9 rounds in that type of fight for either man. Saying Maidana only won 3 or 4 rounds is flat out hypocrisy. Considering he was the ring general in this fight counts plenty. He took an amazing boxers best abilities away from him, that counts for a lot and also all these people refusing to score the body punches that did land.

I'll have to watch the fight a 3rd time to give a round by round breakdown, I dont really do that but I had it a draw going into the 7th, I think Floyd won the 7th, Maidana won the 8th, draw going into the 9th, I think Floyd stepped it up and stayed off the ropes and put enough punches together to win rounds 9-11 and I think the 12th round comes down to preference and could have gone either way.. that makes it a 7-5(My scorecard) or 8-4(If you gave Floyd the 12th) or a draw (If you gave maidana the 12th) This is my opinion.

[I Love Jesus!]

The oscar fight could have gone either way.
Madaina beat Floyd .
PAC will kill Floyd.
Khan could beat him based on last nights performance

Jesus, do guys consider at all who a guy looks good against before you declare him able to beat another guy? Khan is was and always will be ****

[TRUEPINOY]

I think Oscar is on the verge of another meltdown

[Bronx2245]

Maidaina is a BEAST, but Floyd won at least 7 rounds. A rematch is well deserved, but Amir Khan did enough for me to earn a shot too. Unfortunately Amir can't fight in September. The only other matchup I can see is Cotto 2, if he should beat Martinez.

[Spoon23]

Fully agreed

Floyd stan excuses in 3 2 1

He lost and you lot called Pac a bum for besting the p4p 3

What is Floyd when he lost to a c level guy?

Lol that was gold.

Floyd losing to that. Classic.

[Dice]

Maidana did his thing, Floyd came back like the champion he is, as a PBF fan since 99-00, the only man to beat him with the sound on, sound off, the antenna tilted the right way, bad shoulder, no bad shoulder, was Castillo in the first fight.....and then he promptly got blown out in the rematch.