if cotto beats martinez, is he greater than tito?

[IronDanHamza]

Benitez is a good choice, so is Macho Man.

No he's not.

[Espy]

Tito is and always will be a better talent IMO.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

**** no.

tito never got beat down and ran away from a former flyweight.

yup..tito would never moonwalk for 6 rounds against a midget

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Martinez is a shot fighter. So no. Cotto will beat Sergio doesnt make him greater than Tito.

[JmH Reborn]

yup..tito would never moonwalk for 6 rounds against a midget

And Cotto would never quit the sport (2x!!) like a beat down hoe after getting an ass-whupping. No, he pulls himself up by the bootstraps and again tries push himself. Tito was and always will be a man with no heart. When the going got tough, he retired.

Fighting Pac and Floyd are greater challenges than anything Tito ever faced, except Hopkins. Cotto fought Pac at his absolute peak, why is he being discredited?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

And Cotto would never quit the sport (2x!!) like a beat down hoe after getting an ass-whupping. No, he pulls himself up by the bootstraps and again tries push himself. Tito was and always will be a man with no heart. When the going got tough, he retired.

Fighting Pac and Floyd are greater challenges than anything Tito ever faced, except Hopkins. Cotto fought Pac at his absolute peak, why is he being discredited?

you swear like Cotto was gonna turn down those two paydays...heck, anyone would fight PAC and Floyd..that's the lottery

[-PBP-]

It would be close. But look how many 0's Tito took. He ate like 5 or 6 donuts during his career.

[NearHypnos]

Martinez is a shot fighter. So no. Cotto will beat Sergio doesnt make him greater than Tito.

This.

It'll still be a decent win all things considered but no.. Tito would KO Cotto. :|... Benitez would put the beat down as well.

As much as I love Cotto, I couldnt' see Tito or Benitez looking as pitiful as Cotto did vs Pac and Marg 1. Not in their prime

[Espy]

you swear like Cotto was gonna turn down those two paydays...heck, anyone would fight PAC and Floyd..that's the lottery

Besides Danny Garcia

J/k I know what you're saying lol. Heck I'd step into the ring with them if I had the chance for that payday.

[4Corners]

No. But it makes him a real legit Hall of Fame fighter. Right now, he's borderline IMO. His resume leaves a lot to be desired, even though he is one of the better fighters in his time, he lost almost every big fight (Margarito I, Pacquiao, Mayweather, Trout)