if cotto beats martinez, is he greater than tito?

[sugarsmosley]

i apologize if you've seen this thread before, i havent so just want to know from NSB

simple question, if cotto pulls off the huge upset becomes middleweight champ, is he greater than felix trinidad?

[El Angel]

In the eyes of PR's, he'll never pass Tito.

[sugarsmosley]

In the eyes of PR's, he'll never pass Tito.

i was originally going to ask if he would be the greatest PR fighter of all time lol. imo if he beats martinez, you can for sure make a case hes right there with tito

[JmH Reborn]

Tito is a quitter, Cotto will always be greater than him

[Pete Nice]

If he wins against Martinez, then yes, he surpasses Tito.

[sugarsmosley]

Tito is a quitter, Cotto will always be greater than him

tito is a quitter compared to who?

[FightingWords]

Nay, Tito has a better Res.. A win over Whitaker alone trumps anything Cotto has done. Let alone giving Oscar his first loss (albeit controversial)..

[Chuckguy]

Yes! Best of luck Cotto.

[Check_hooks]

In my opinion, absolutely

[Left Hook Tua]

**** no.

tito never got beat down and ran away from a former flyweight.