if cotto beats martinez, is he greater than tito?

[MattysEyeThough]

Seems like a reasonable answer from a guy with a cotto avi..

Right, because injuries affecting the eye ONLY apply to Mexican's "margarito" and Argentinean's "Lucas Matthysse"


Bias is comedy.

[Dodger07]

so do you think cotto vs tito @ welter prime for prime tito smokes him?

i dont think any1 thought tito had a chance in hell against bhop anyway. but yes he did look awful in that fight

Most were picking tito to win going into the hopkins fight and Bhop beat his ass.

http://www.cyberboxingzone.com/boxing/jd92601.htm

[Dodger07]

Both are great puerto rican fighters but Trinidad >>>> Cotto clearly imo.

Trinidad has Wins over Whitaker, De la Hoya, Vargas, Reid, Mayorga, Camacho, Blocker, Carr, Campas, Joppy against losses to Hopkins, Wright, and Jones Jr. (All losses were to great bigger fighters with tough styles for him near the end of his career)

Cottos wins include Martinez, Mosley, Clottey, Judah, Quintana, Torres, Pinto, Malignaggi, Bailey, Foreman, Margarito II, and Mayorga against losses to Margarito, Pacquiao, Mayweather and Trout.(A few of those losses were either in his prime or against smaller foes or fighters not regarded as being great)

Trindidad at this point has a better resume and Id pick him in a H2H Matchup as well.

[Daniel_T5]

pitiful? like tito against hopkins, roy and winky??

[Puya]

so do you think cotto vs tito @ welter prime for prime tito smokes him?

i dont think any1 thought tito had a chance in hell against bhop anyway. but yes he did look awful in that fight

PRIME Tito at 147, 154 was veeery hard to beat. Winky was very good but the fight took place after Tito's comeback which he was pass his prime.

Tito at any weigh, prime, past prime would have beat Margarito by a beat down. One thing is to be able to take a hit and another thing is to be hit by Trinidad. Margarito's chin will be there to be hit at will.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

pitiful? like tito against hopkins, roy and winky??

And also like cotto vs manny, margs, trout