Originally posted by coghaugen
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Eubank: How I would've beaten a peak RJJ!
Collapse
-
Originally posted by coghaugen View Post'ATG' is subjective nonsense. In hindsight maybe he was better than we thought at the time, but I actually lived through that time as a boxing nut and Hopkins just a body. In fact he was just a body until he fought Trinidad.
The guy is overrated since Trinidad. Who has he beat? Nobody. Lost twice to Jermain Taylor, the first particularly good fighter he fought in 12 years. Lost to an old Calzaghe, looked **** against an old Winky and shot Jones. Quit against Dawson, and faked injury also against Calzagne and Jones - hardly the sign of a great fighter, is it? The great fighters of the past were turning in their graves.
What about dominating Tarver? KO'ing Glen Johnson...
Comment
-
Originally posted by coghaugen View Post'ATG' is subjective nonsense. In hindsight maybe he was better than we thought at the time, but I actually lived through that time as a boxing nut and Hopkins just a body. In fact he was just a body until he fought Trinidad.
The guy is overrated since Trinidad. Who has he beat? Nobody. Lost twice to Jermain Taylor, the first particularly good fighter he fought in 12 years. Lost to an old Calzaghe, looked **** against an old Winky and shot Jones. Quit against Dawson, and faked injury also against Calzagne and Jones - hardly the sign of a great fighter, is it? The great fighters of the past were turning in their graves.
Comment
-
Originally posted by richardt View PostThe great fighters of the past also lost to top fighters and some to lesser fighters but his position as an ATG is sealed. He is and will be seen as that by historians that way. Nothing you can do about that.
Comment
-
Originally posted by IMDAZED View PostHopkins was ranked in the p4p before he fought Tito. Actually he had been there for years because his skills were very, very impressive and it was clear that he was a couple notches above the other champions in the division.
Comment
-
Originally posted by coghaugen View PostPavlik, Pascal and Glencoffe were Very limited. Even Carl Froch and Clinton Woods beat Pascal and Glen!
Unless you're saying Eubank is a greater fighter than Hopkins with the greater resume?
Comment
Comment