is my p4p list better than ring magazines one?

[jas]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

No. They're both crap.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[Mike D]

IMO Danny Garcia is waaayyyy too high. I think he's borderline top ten right now at best. Another nice win or two and I'd be ready to put him in that company. Provod shouldn't be there. His signature fights are a win over Mike Alvarado and a moral victory loss to Tim Bradley. Ruslan at best is just inside in the top 20, and I'd guess that a lot of people wouldn't even have him top 20 at all.

I'd also like to see Lara get one more impressive win to his resume before seeing him in any top ten.

[hhs661]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

My beef with your list is this... You have Bradley lower than Pacquiao although Timmy just beat 2 top 10 guys on your list, back to back. Pacquiao defeated Rios but still got clocked by JMM before that. A guy Bradley handled quite easily.

I'd still have JMM ahead of Manny due to their last bout. JMM faced a far superior fighter, lost, yet still has that win over Manny. A guy like Ruslan, exciting as he is, isn't top 10 material as of yet. He's in that "Gatti List" of fighters that I think Lampley used to do, IMO.

Ring's ranking of Canelo is crap. Eff that. But I just don't see what career accomplishments has to do with up to date p4p rankings. My 2 cents

[MAXIMUS~RICO~13]

I agree with rings more!

[dc3383]

Danny Garcia should be there over Canelo; and no way in hell ruslan deserves a spot.

[Larry the boss]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

your list is utter ****

how is Rigo over Bradley and Garcia??? both have better wins and thicker resumes with 0 loses

Provetkin top 10??based on what a Alvarado win?

and you dropped Juan lower yet raised Manny??why?

and you drop Sergio for a poor perfomance even tho he beat a top 5 160 fighter yet Manny remains after beating an unranked Rios coming off of a lose?

[El Angel]

They're both pretty bad TBH.

[jas]

your list is utter ****

how is Rigo over Bradley and Garcia??? both have better wins and thicker resumes with 0 loses

Provetkin top 10??based on what a Alvarado win?

and you dropped Juan lower yet raised Manny??why?

and you drop Sergio for a poor perfomance even tho he beat a top 5 160 fighter yet Manny remains after beating an unranked Rios coming off of a lose?

stop hatin on manny, not my fault marquez be on those power pellets

[JaYDeuce11]

Yea Manny does not desrve being no higher than 5 , no way u canout him higher than bradley or marquez at this point. P4p is current best not their all time achievements.
Really wanna out some stevenson n ggg on their after the year they had but need that ONE big win like rigo got n garcia
-Mayweather
-Ward
- Bradley
- klit
- rigo
- Martinez
- Marquez
- Pacquiao
- Froch
-Danny Garcia