is my p4p list better than ring magazines one?

[techliam]

P4P is fantasy so both lists are just as good (or bad) as eachother.

P4P doesn't matter, at all, only in terms of marketability for no.1...

I wish people would stop assuming P4P actually means anything. Maybe it did, once upon a time. But not today

[mathed]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

I feel the embolden are out of line, personally

[MarkPosadas26]

It should be:

1.) Manny Pacquiao (8th time world champ. Fighting the best out there)
2.) Floyd Mayweather Jr. (Ducking the best out there, waiting to get old)
3.) Timothy Bradley (Beaten piss drinker)
4.) Juan Manuel Marquez (Beaten Pacman by stepping on its foot)
5.) Sergio Martinez (Inactive but has great boxing skills)
6.) Mikey Garcia (Young and has a great boxing talent)
7.) Andre Ward (I don't know him actually)
8.) Yuriorkis Gamboa (I like his boxing style and skills but he's inactive for years)
9.) Wladimir Klitschko (Boring)
10.) No more.

[takingaim]

Martinez & Canelo being in there is a joke.

[El Angel]

It should be:

1.) Manny Pacquiao (8th time world champ. Fighting the best out there)
2.) Floyd Mayweather Jr. (Ducking the best out there, waiting to get old)
3.) Timothy Bradley (Beaten piss drinker)
4.) Juan Manuel Marquez (Beaten Pacman by stepping on its foot)
5.) Sergio Martinez (Inactive but has great boxing skills)
6.) Mikey Garcia (Young and has a great boxing talent)
7.) Andre Ward (I don't know him actually)
8.) Yuriorkis Gamboa (I like his boxing style and skills but he's inactive for years)
9.) Wladimir Klitschko (Boring)
10.) No more.

[Tay Roc]

OP: you should apply for a job at with The Ring magazine. You'd fit right in with those rankings.

[13777]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

For me the top 10 are (jmo, most of you will **** on my list):

Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Andre Ward
Wladimir Klitschko
Timothy Bradley
Takashi Uchiyama
Guillermo Rigondeaux
Shinsuke Yamanaka
Tomoki Kameda
Danny Garcia
Yuriorkis Gamboa

There are also some Russians you've never heard of that I would pick over certain title holders.

And then there are GGG and Lomachenko who could break through in 2014.

[krazyn8tive]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

How the fcuk is manny on there? Losing to Bradley, getting iced by Marquez, and beating a walking heavy bag?

[elgranluchadore]

1 ali raymi
2 tyson fury
3 wlad
4 floyd
5 tiger muhammad
6 sergio
7 bradley
8 marquez
9 pacroid
10 garcia

[soul_survivor]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

That's a terrible list man, why are Lara and Prov there??? Froch is miles better than them both and done a lot more too. How can Stevenson not be on there, at least at 10?? LOL come on dog