is my p4p list better than ring magazines one?

[DiegoFuego]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

You are clearly on the F side meth

[Larry the boss]

Floyd
ward
bradley
wlad
martinez
danny
mikey
juan
manny
rigo

[Furn]

No Ali Raymi ?

You fail.

[Kingjames6Flee]

Great list except Provo needs a few more key wins.

[Kingjames6Flee]

Floyd
ward
bradley
wlad
martinez
danny
mikey
juan
manny
rigo

That one is actually better, except I wouldn't put mikey in just yet.

[samouraļ]

My beef with your list is this... You have Bradley lower than Pacquiao although Timmy just beat 2 top 10 guys on your list, back to back. Pacquiao defeated Rios but still got clocked by JMM before that. A guy Bradley handled quite easily.

I'd still have JMM ahead of Manny due to their last bout. JMM faced a far superior fighter, lost, yet still has that win over Manny. A guy like Ruslan, exciting as he is, isn't top 10 material as of yet. He's in that "Gatti List" of fighters that I think Lampley used to do, IMO.

Ring's ranking of Canelo is crap. Eff that. But I just don't see what career accomplishments has to do with up to date p4p rankings. My 2 cents

I wouldn't call Bradley "far superior" to Marquez. Styles make fights. Yes, Bradley did hand JMM his ass, but I don't see how that means he's far superior. We've got to remember that Marquez ain't a young man anymore, either.

[teddycanyon]

Floyd
Ward
Bradley
Klitschko
JMM
Rigo
Pac
Swift
Donaire
Matthysse

It's unpopular to have fighters in the top ten coming off losses but Donaire and Matthysse lost to really top-notch level fighters so I give them a pass. I don't have Sergio in there as he's looked unimpressive for a while now, and not enough from Mikey Garcia, Ggg, Stevenson or Lara to put them in there yet.

[teddycanyon]

And I think the TS's list isn't great---But it beats the Ring's list . No one in their right mind would say Canelo deserves to be called one of the ten best fighters in the world after his last performance

[hhs661]

I wouldn't call Bradley "far superior" to Marquez. Styles make fights. Yes, Bradley did hand JMM his ass, but I don't see how that means he's far superior. We've got to remember that Marquez ain't a young man anymore, either.

Bradley is far superior to Rios.. I wasn't meaning JMM. That's why I don't see how he'd have Manny ahead of those 2.

[Jloro]

Floyd
ward
bradley
wlad
martinez
danny
mikey
juan
manny
rigo

I like this but I would prolly drop Marquez and Mikey

Floyd
Ward
Bradley
Klitschko
JMM
Rigo
Pac
Swift
Donaire
Matthysse

It's unpopular to have fighters in the top ten coming off losses but Donaire and Matthysse lost to really top-notch level fighters so I give them a pass. I don't have Sergio in there as he's looked unimpressive for a while now, and not enough from Mikey Garcia, Ggg, Stevenson or Lara to put them in there yet.

LMFAO you have Donaire and Matthysse in there but not Sergio Martinez?
and JMM at #5 p4p seems crazy to me, most WW's beat him now lmao