is my p4p list better than ring magazines one?

[RlCKY]

ring magazine p4p list

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. bradley
4. wlad klitschko
5. sergio martinez
6. marquez
7. pacquaio
8. rigondeaux
9. saul alvarez
10. carl froch

my p4p list:

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux - HIGHER
4. pacquaio - HIGHER
5. danny garcia - HIGHER
6. bradley - LOWER
7. wlad klitschko - LOWER
8. marquez - LOWER
9. erislandy lara - HIGHER
10. provodnikov - HIGHER

EXCLUDES: sergio who barely got past murray, canelo hypejob, froch crossing his feet with his chin up in the air.

my criteria:

1) most important is recent wins
2) career accomplishments
3) least important is excitement

This is a horrible list, if for the only reason that the criteria is completely contradictory to the fighters. LMAO.

I'm not good with lists myself, but personally, using you're criteria, Carlos Molina has a better resume at 154 than Lara, sans the official results of the fights he participated in. the same can be said for Molina's Chavez and Alvarado fights. So as much as I would disagree with Molina or Lara for a top 10 spot, I would have to give it to Molina if I was gonna give it to either guy.

Floyd
ward
bradley
wlad
martinez
danny
mikey
juan
manny
rigo

That's a much better list. I'd drop Mikey to 10 and move everyone up a spot.

[RlCKY]

For me the top 10 are (jmo, most of you will **** on my list):

Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Andre Ward
Wladimir Klitschko
Timothy Bradley
Takashi Uchiyama
Guillermo Rigondeaux
Shinsuke Yamanaka
Tomoki Kameda
Danny Garcia
Yuriorkis Gamboa

There are also some Russians you've never heard of that I would pick over certain title holders.

And then there are GGG and Lomachenko who could break through in 2014.

Lomachenko would have to fight 5 times and beat Salido(obviously) Garcia, Mares/Gonzales, Rigo, and LSC. I think that would get him on the list in 2014.

[4Corners]

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. Bradley
4. Rigondeaux
5. Wlad
6. Marquez
7. Pacquiao
8. D Garcia
9. Martinez
10. M Garcia

Mikey gets there for me. People will crap on that, saying he got dropped by Roman Martinez, and stunned by Burgos. But he won the RING title at 126, picked up wins over Salido and Lopez. Won a title at 130, picked up two solid wins there over Martinez and Burgos.

[DeadLikeMe]

I didn't think it was possible to make a worse list than ring, I guess I was wrong. Just awful.

[jas]

I didn't think it was possible to make a worse list than ring, I guess I was wrong. Just awful.

[DeadLikeMe]

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. Bradley
4. Rigondeaux
5. Wlad
6. Marquez
7. Pacquiao
8. D Garcia
9. Martinez
10. M Garcia

Mikey gets there for me. People will crap on that, saying he got dropped by Roman Martinez, and stunned by Burgos. But he won the RING title at 126, picked up wins over Salido and Lopez. Won a title at 130, picked up two solid wins there over Martinez and Burgos.

I agree with this list. The 10 spot can always go to a plethora of worthy fights.

[jas]

i've forgotten more about boxing than you've ever learnt. i am bert sugar reincarnated.