2013 Boxingscene Fighter of the Year - Guillermo Rigondeaux

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Has Dawson ever beat a young fighter??His most impressive wins are against guy's in their mid 30's and up..Dawson is overrated,once again,that win can not come close to beating Matt's Marquez or Prov imo..

Oh lawd this guy

Provodnikov is better than Chad Dawson now? I can't believe you can't see how far up Bradley's ring-piece you are. Oh and Stevenson blitzed Dawson in 1 round whereas Bradley went life and death and arguably LOST to Provodnikov.

You're criticising Dawson for beating guys in their 30's without even realising that you're gnoshing off Bradley for beating a 40 year old man

Get some perspective.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Legacy? That's even dumber. It's FIGHTER of the YEAR. Not who has the greater legacy or who made the most money. Absolutely irrelevant factors.

What a fighters have done in this yr is a part of their legacy is it not..Or do you believe it goes away after the yr is done..Fuccking moron..

[Rome-By-Ko]

Oh lawd this guy

Provodnikov is better than Chad Dawson now? I can't believe you can't see how far up Bradley's ring-piece you are. Oh and Stevenson blitzed Dawson in 1 round whereas Bradley went life and death and arguably LOST to Provodnikov.

You're criticising Dawson for beating guys in their 30's without even realising that you're gnoshing off Bradley for beating a 40 year old man

Get some perspective.

You talk of perspective,Bradley had imo FOTY with Prov,who was coming off 4 wins in a row,Marquez had his best win of his career before fighting Bradley..Stevenson beat Dawson moving back up in weight after being stopped and having his azz handed to him by Ward..Talk about getting some perspective,fuccking moron..

[RubenSonny]

Dawson was ruined by draining himself, by the time he fought Stevenson he was done at the top level. It was really just a minor upset, Stevenson was in the right place at the right time, it's not a good win. Cloud is trash and so is Bellew, he's not a legitimate contender for FOTY.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Anyone who is not taking into account that Mayweather broke the PPV rec is just being foolish and a bit unfair as well..Not only did Mayweather fight the guy everyone wanted him to fight,but he beat him easy and broke PPV rec's at the same time..Clearly a top guy for FOTY..

[IronDanHamza]

Objectivity man, come on.

Floyd UD'd Guerrero whose best win at 147 was...wait for it...Andre Berto who just lost via KO to Karass.
Floyd UD'd Canelo whose only real win was...wait for it...Austin Trout (disputed) who just lost to Lara.

Stevenson KO'd Ring champ Dawson whose best win was atg Bernard Hopkins.
Stevenson TKO'd IBF champ Cloud whose best win was Glen Johnson
Stevenson KO'd #6 Bellew whose best win was #7 Isaac Chilemba
Stevenson avenged a KO defeat by stopping Darnell Boone in 6 rounds

This guy is running through the best in the division (three top 6 opponents incl. the champ) and you want to give the award to Mayweather for beating a blown up lightweight and a guy with no resume.

Objectivity That's hilarious coming from you.

You use Ring Rankings to justify everyone but Mayweather.

"This guy is running through the best in the division (three top 6 opponents incl. the champ)"

Mayweather beat the #2 guy at WW and the #2 guy at Jr MW. Rankings only don't count when it's Floyd?

"Bellew's best win was Chilemba who was #7"

How many "real wins" does Chilemba have? Why did you conveniently leave that out but not when criticizing Canelo?

Wait, you said Canelo was the fight Floyd should take didn't you? You said it was the best fight available for Mayweather didn't you? But now you're talking about it in a critical way as if it's not a good win.

You put the word "Disputed" in brackets next to Trout but conveniently don't put that same word next to Glen Johnson for Cloud? Why? And Cloud wasn't the IBF Champion either. Incase you forgot he'd just lost it by being shut out by Hopkins. Conveniently didn't put "Coming off a loss" in brackets next to Dawson and Cloud. I wonder if you would if Mayweather fought someone coming off a loss.

Try harder to cover up your bias.

[~AK49~]

Imo, maidanas annihilating Lopez was more impressive/better than Garcia's win over zab 'refuse to let his hands go' Judah.

The wins over matthysse and broner were both great, and effectively a push between them.

So essentially, I believe maidana has had a better year than garcia.

[RubenSonny]

Objectivity That's hilarious coming from you.

You use Ring Rankings to justify everyone but Mayweather.

"This guy is running through the best in the division (three top 6 opponents incl. the champ)"

Mayweather beat the #2 guy at WW and the #2 guy at Jr MW. Rankings only don't count when it's Floyd?

"Bellew's best win was Chilemba who was #7"

How many "real wins" does Chilemba have? Why did you conveniently leave that out but not when criticizing Canelo?

Wait, you said Canelo was the fight Floyd should take didn't you? You said it was the best fight available for Mayweather didn't you? But now you're talking about it in a critical way as if it's not a good win.

You put the word "Disputed" in brackets next to Trout but conveniently don't put that same word next to Glen Johnson for Cloud? Why?

Try harder to cover up your bias.

I'm pretty sure he said Canelo had a great chance to beat Floyd right after the Trout fight talking up his defense and being particular impressed by the KD

[Rome-By-Ko]

Imo, maidanas annihilating Lopez was more impressive/better than Garcia's win over zab 'refuse to let his hands go' Judah.

The wins over matthysse and broner were both great, and effectively a push between them.

So essentially, I believe maidana has had a better year than garcia.

Noway in hell..

[IronDanHamza]

I'm pretty sure he said Canelo had a great chance to beat Floyd right after the Trout fight talking up his defense and being particular impressed by the KD

Mayweather was ducking Trout in his eyes but apparently now he doesn't think highly of Trout.

Canelo was a threat to Mayweather, he was the fight to make, the fight he would duck.

Now, it's a win against a fighter with no resume.

Convenient.