Prime Mayweather vs. Prime Cotto: who wins?

[Reloaded]

The 154 version of Cotto beats the crap out of the 145 version .

[SkillspayBills]

In 2007-2008 Floyd would have beaten the breaks off of Cotto. Keep in mind Cotto always had subpar stamina, Floyd drowns him in deep waters.

[El Angel]

In 2007-2008 Floyd would have beaten the breaks off of Cotto. Keep in mind Cotto always had subpar stamina, Floyd drowns him in deep waters.

Cotto came on strong down the stretch during his prime, until he fought Margarito. Stopped Judah and Urkal late, only Mosley got him to show fatigue late, even then, it wasn't enough for him to lose the fight.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

you should have never brought up the beltran fight...........on one end you had a guy being hurt (burns) and his jaw was broken. hanging on for dear life in many of the rounds. cotto vs mosley was a back and fourth fight with both guys for the most part giving just as good as they got. 2 totally different fights..........and i gave cotto the fight by one point which means i didn't have him losing on my card. but the people who had it a draw is totally understandable..........it's the kind of fight that you can change one or 2 points.

burns and beltran isn't that at all............


so what are you really arguing here?

Im arguing that there can be fights which are separated by a couple of points but there is a clear winner.

How do you give Cotto the fight by 1 point? What did you score it in rounds?

[El Angel]

Im arguing that there can be fights which are separated by a couple of points but there is a clear winner.

How do you give Cotto the fight by 1 point? What did you score it in rounds?

I wondered that too. Even round is the only possibility.

[Godsfly]

I wondered that too. Even round is the only possibility.

cotto 1 4 5 6 7 11

mosley 2 3 8 9 10


& 12th being even................(the 12th was as close as it gets)

go back and watch it...............

[sicko]

Any Era! Any Weight Class! Mayweather Dominates Cotto REGARDLESS!

Not disrespect to Cotto he is always a guy I liked and rooted for but COME ON, during this Mayweather's ERA when it comes to SKILLS he has been and still is Head And Shoulders Above The Rest

I know it hurts his haters and it is frustrating that they been looking for someone to come along and knock him off and the fact that it hasn't came close to happening really makes them hate him even more but...

YOU CANNOT DENY THE SKILLS!

[A-Wolf]

Mayweather wins every time. Any time.

[Boxing Goat]

Mayweather would still have won but it would have been a tougher fight.

I had Mayweather winning 8-4 on the cards.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

A prime floyd beats prime cotto,,

would always be a close fight, but floyd got too many tools at his disposal and cotto prime or not, has always been easy to hit....

floyd wins an action fight if this happened 05-08