Is Wladimir Klitschko a top 5 ATG heavyweight?

[Madjab]

I don't think I added. NO he is not a top 5 HW.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Wlad would easily crush Frazier, Holmes, Marciano and Louis. You just can't compare them with him in terms of athleticism and Marciano's style fits perfectly to Wlad's style.

I will agree with you that Wlad would beat marcaino, frazier and louis,,,

But no way in hell he beats holmes.... Holmes was a warrior with a huge will to win,,, Highly underrated champion... Holmes is top 3 for me...

[LacedUp]

I believe Willard is slightly underrated, but you do know that he only successfully defended the title once in those four years, right?

Yes but he had 'unofficial' fights. Plus, he has good wins outside of his reign. And I'm not trying to pass him on as an ATG, just that he was a lineal champ who has a better win on his record than arguably anyone Wlad has faced.

[LacedUp]

Wlad would easily crush Frazier, Holmes, Marciano and Louis. You just can't compare them with him in terms of athleticism and Marciano's style fits perfectly to Wlad's style.

Dude did you notice how this thread was not in the fantasy fight section?

Stop trolling my threads.

[Weltschmerz]

This has been suggested quite a few times recently.

What do you think?

****ing moron. Get a hobby already.you're obsessed about Wlad, you little twat.

[LacedUp]

****ing moron. Get a hobby already.you're obsessed about Wlad, you little twat.

Didn't I just tell you to stop trolling my thread? I bet I'm not as obsessed as you are.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

After much thinking,,, I cant put wlad top 5 ATG,,, Yes he did dominant an era, but so have alot of fighters,,,,

Just cant put him in top 5,,, Not a knock on wlad, I just think there is more qualified candidates like Ali, Lewis, Holmes, Louis, Foreman, holyfield,

Wlad is higher than say bowe and moorer, but not top 5

[beez721]

Wlad doesn't have the skill to even tough Louis, but if he did tag him, then yes, Louis would stand up to it fine.

Louis was around 195 lbs in his prime. I cant see how on earth he could take a clean wlad right hand or left hook without going down. that's not to say wlad is as great but come on now

[LacedUp]

Louis was around 195 lbs in his prime. I cant see how on earth he could take a clean wlad right hand or left hook without going down. that's not to say wlad is as great but come on now

Haye was 200 pound in his prime, he took a Wlad shot pretty well.

[beez721]

Haye was 200 pound in his prime, he took a Wlad shot pretty well.

haye's chin did surprise me but he was moving around and never really got hit flush with wlads best shot