Is Wladimir Klitschko a top 5 ATG heavyweight?

[Jedi Vader]

fantasy match up in judging him on his latest 8/9 years Wld is the best ever.

But from a legacy point of view hes top 5.

He has more knockouts than people have wins and if he stays healthy can still reign till about 42 imo.

Let's just assume you have him in 5th place right now.

What 4 do you have ahead of him?

[slimshandy69]

Let's just assume you have him in 5th place right now.

What 4 do you have ahead of him?

joe Louis for title defences, lennox lewis, Rocky Marciano and Vitali.

Before 2008 I had lennox lewis best ever in terms of fantasy match up. I now have WLAD nuber 1, vitali number 2 and lennox 3.

These guys would destroy any heavy weight from any era when on top form.

[LacedUp]

joe Louis for title defences, lennox lewis, Rocky Marciano and Vitali.

Before 2008 I had lennox lewis best ever in terms of fantasy match up. I now have WLAD nuber 1, vitali number 2 and lennox 3.

These guys would destroy any heavy weight from any era when on top form.

I'm seriously beginning to doubt whether or not you have actually seen these guys fight or if you have just gone by Wikipedia.

Marciano and Vitali in top 5... Haha that was a good one. Thanks for bringing some much needed humor into this thread.

[slimshandy69]

I'm seriously beginning to doubt whether or not your actually seen these guys fight or if you have just gone by Wikipedia.

Marciano and Vitali in top 5... Haha that was a good one. Thanks for bringing some much needed humor into this thread.

never lost, undefeated...

[LacedUp]

never lost, undefeated...

Dude you don't know anything about boxing.

Up in the right hand corner.. It says "log-out" - click it.

[Thickback]

Due to lack of competition in the HW division during his time, I can't give him top 10.

[yoz]

joe Louis for title defences, lennox lewis, Rocky Marciano and Vitali.

Before 2008 I had lennox lewis best ever in terms of fantasy match up. I now have WLAD nuber 1, vitali number 2 and lennox 3.

These guys would destroy any heavy weight from any era when on top form.

HA HA HA HA

[Thickback]

joe Louis for title defences, lennox lewis, Rocky Marciano and Vitali.

Before 2008 I had lennox lewis best ever in terms of fantasy match up. I now have WLAD nuber 1, vitali number 2 and lennox 3.

These guys would destroy any heavy weight from any era when on top form.

Oh my word....do you really mean that????

[jacksonmann]

Probably about No.15

His chin would let him down against some of the big punchers of yesteryear

[LacedUp]

HA HA HA HA

I know you like Wlad and that's fair. At least you can explain why you think he's up there etc and have realistic approach to his legacy. But this guy.. He gives good fans like you a bad name.

Oh my word....do you really mean that????

Yes he does. It's sad.