Can you be considered an ATG when these are your 10 best wins?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • JAB5239
    Dallas Cowboys
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Dec 2007
    • 28272
    • 5,328
    • 4,515
    • 73,018

    #251
    Originally posted by BattlingNelson
    So I ask this question in post 6:



    A reasonable question that needs answering before you seriously can try to determine whether Vitali is an ATG or not.

    Oddly enough the TS, who is a mod of boxingscene's historysection BTW, ignores the question and spends the next several days laughing and ridiculing the posters who voted Vitali was an ATG. Finally 170 posts later we get the definition that is paramount:




    In other words you have to be considered top 20 in your division all-time to be considered an ATG.

    Now Jab and his henchmen has spent about 100+ posts ridiculing those saying Vitali was an ATG, so one would think that Jab, being a scholar of the sports history, has Vitali ranked far away from all-time greatness. I mean how else can you justify all that bullying and ridiculing?

    Let's see the answer:




    So Vitali JUST misses the cut! Ahahahahaha!

    What a joke you are Jab. How can you justify this ridicule towards posters who just might happen to rank Vitali no. 20 all-time instead instead of JUST missing the cut as you do? We are talking about highly subjective all-time rankings where the difference might be as low as one single place! Talk about having an agenda!


    Wauw!

    Bat, are you seriously still whining? The people have spoken, see the poll for confirmation. And if you can't understand the opening question I can't help you. Its been explained in detail throughout the whole thread with no answers for it. You keep on trolling me the old pal, its all good. I'm getting a good laugh from it!

    Comment

    • JAB5239
      Dallas Cowboys
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Dec 2007
      • 28272
      • 5,328
      • 4,515
      • 73,018

      #252
      Originally posted by Uturn
      H2H Vitali is an ATG. Looking at his resume you cannot declare Vitali as a true ATG. His resume is lacking, there just aren't any stand out wins. If he had beaten Lewis then things may have been different. Even beating an old Lewis would have been something.
      Thank you, thank you, thank you.

      Comment

      • BattlingNelson
        Mod a Phukka
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Mar 2008
        • 29881
        • 3,255
        • 3,200
        • 286,536

        #253
        Originally posted by JAB5239
        Bat, are you seriously still whining? The people have spoken, see the poll for confirmation. And if you can't understand the opening question I can't help you. Its been explained in detail throughout the whole thread with no answers for it. You keep on trolling me the old pal, its all good. I'm getting a good laugh from it!
        Yeah. Just ignore the points I made. You got destroyed and your (obvious) agenda was exposed (again).

        Comment

        • JAB5239
          Dallas Cowboys
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Dec 2007
          • 28272
          • 5,328
          • 4,515
          • 73,018

          #254
          Originally posted by BattlingNelson
          Yeah. Just ignore the points I made. You got destroyed and your (obvious) agenda was exposed (again).
          I got destroyed? Not a single person including yourself has been able to explain how Vittles can be an ATG with his weak resume. Nuthuggers like to say he can beat this one or that one so he's an ATG. Sorry son but that's not how it works. Name me one all time great without a win over a HOF fighter. You can't. But we should make an exception for ole Vitaly because you're sweet on him. So you go ahead and keep talking out your ass about how I "got destroyed". But just remember, more than 3/4 of the voters agree with me. Did they all get destroyed too? Do they all have an agenda?

          Now take your bottle and go find an Andre Ward thread to cry in.

          Comment

          • Poet682006
            Banned
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Mar 2007
            • 17924
            • 1,181
            • 1,350
            • 26,849

            #255
            Hey JAB? Did you get a load of Eddie Chambers tonight? So much for the idea that today's Heavyweight contenders would look great if it wasn't for the Klits :hahahaha9:

            Poet

            Comment

            • JAB5239
              Dallas Cowboys
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Dec 2007
              • 28272
              • 5,328
              • 4,515
              • 73,018

              #256
              Originally posted by poet682006
              Hey JAB? Did you get a load of Eddie Chambers tonight? So much for the idea that today's Heavyweight contenders would look great if it wasn't for the Klits :hahahaha9:

              Poet
              Been working all day and night and haven't seen it yet. What happened?

              Comment

              • Poet682006
                Banned
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Mar 2007
                • 17924
                • 1,181
                • 1,350
                • 26,849

                #257
                Originally posted by JAB5239
                Been working all day and night and haven't seen it yet. What happened?
                Chambers lost a lopsided UD to a non-entity Cruiserweight. Scores were 99-91, 99-91, 97-93. He was hideous.

                Poet

                Comment

                • JAB5239
                  Dallas Cowboys
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Dec 2007
                  • 28272
                  • 5,328
                  • 4,515
                  • 73,018

                  #258
                  Originally posted by poet682006
                  Chambers lost a lopsided UD to a non-entity Cruiserweight. Scores were 99-91, 99-91, 97-93. He was hideous.

                  Poet
                  The same Chambers who beat Dimetrenko, Peter, Rossy and arguably Adamek with one arm? Lol, yeah the heavyweight division is at an all time high! Those guys would seem great if the Klitschko's weren't around...lol...who was the genius who said that?
                  Last edited by JAB5239; 08-04-2013, 02:09 AM.

                  Comment

                  • Poet682006
                    Banned
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Mar 2007
                    • 17924
                    • 1,181
                    • 1,350
                    • 26,849

                    #259
                    Originally posted by JAB5239
                    The same Chambers who beat Dimetrenko, Peter, Rossy and arguably Adamek with one arm? Lol, yeah the heavyweight division is at an all time high! Those guys would seem great if the Klitschko's weren't around...lil...who was the denius who said that?
                    Hell, which one of the usual suspects DIDN'T say it? :hahahaha9:

                    Poet

                    Comment

                    • hitman smax
                      Contender
                      Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                      • Apr 2013
                      • 316
                      • 23
                      • 9
                      • 6,525

                      #260
                      Originally posted by LacedUp
                      Spinks (world champ in 2 weight classes), undefeated, Bruno (two times world champ), Berbick (world champ)/Larry holmes

                      Name Sanders or Peter's three biggest wins.
                      Spinks is the only significant name on your list, and he fought Tyson after an over year long layoff.

                      The truth is, Spinks was never truly a confident fighter after his battles with Holmes. He ducked Tony Tucker, and required serious incentive and convincing to step in the ring with Tyson.

                      He retired right after that fight, but the truth is, he was already mentally done before it.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP