Who had better defense, Floyd Mayweather Jr, SRL, Whitaker, Broner?

[UTEP]

It's Mayweather by a landslide. There is a reason he got the nickname "pretty boy".

No he got that nickname in jail after beating his first baby mama.

[BUNGALOWS]

DLT's the same guy that made a thread saying, "Broner was impressive", and you got abused in your own thread.

NO ONE TAKES YOU SERIOUSLY. You're the resident Floyd fanatic. It's on comical levels at this point. You're the epitome of a boxing gimmick. The guy that has no sanity when it comes to Floyd.

That's all there is to it.

[lx!!]

Do yourself a favor and actually watch the sport, this was obviously a lame attempt at knocking Floyd. Mayweather has fought higher caliber opponents than JCV, McGirt, Hurtado and Roger Mayweather, and not once did he hit the canvas. Pernell is probably my favorite boxer of all time, so I'm gonna say it's a tie, Pernell getting dropped quite a few times was due to a lot of showboating as he found it too easy, but when he was on his game and not clowning around he was nearly impossible to hit cleanly. I won't argue with anyone that picks Whitaker.

Lol! "Watch the sport"??? Ok whatever makes you feel better. Everyone you mentioned in your idols resume isn't higher caliber than what sweat pea has faced btw... Nelson, Oscar (when he wasn't a part time fighter), Tito (a version that Floyd would have ducked), Chavez sr, Paez & Ramirez to name a few (none were past prime btw) so you should do your self a favor & "watch the sport".

[Gatling]

Lol! "Watch the sport"??? Ok whatever makes you feel better. Everyone you mentioned in your idols resume isn't higher caliber than what sweat pea has faced btw... Nelson, Oscar (when he wasn't a part time fighter), Tito (a version that Floyd would have ducked), Chavez sr, Paez & Ramirez to name a few (none were past prime btw) so you should do your self a favor & "watch the sport".

Ramirez and Chavez SR weren't prime versions.

[Kbmunro]

david haye in the first 6 rounds of the klit fight > mayweather









lol

[EDD1]

That goes more towards his abilities in mixing up offense and defense. You can't count that against his defense.

Guy could stand and trade with you without holding, and slips everything. Floyd holds when he's on the inside. HUGE DIFFERENCE.

The slips are what make the difference for me on this question

[SplitSecond]

david haye in the first 6 rounds of the klit fight > mayweather









lol

on a serious note, david haye has some insane reflexes, probabley better than roy jones, but his legs are slower, i've watched every roy jones fight, and he hasn't impressed me as much as haye has with some of his slipping, sometimes it's just like "wow", his reflexes are insane

too bad he has no stamina and isn't as good, but he has all the talent

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Quote:

Originally Posted by .:: JSFD26 ::.

Idk if I would put Sweet Pea first. He seemed to wanna **** every once in a while.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

That goes more towards his abilities in mixing up offense and defense. You can't count that against his defense.

Guy could stand and trade with you without holding, and slips everything. Floyd holds when he's on the inside. HUGE DIFFERENCE.

You have a point but I guess the reason I'd pick Floyd is cause he's more of a defense first type guy. He's more defensively minded in a way.

Floyd might not be the best inside fighter but he can defend himself on the inside without clinching too.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[boliodogs]

I voted for Mayweather. I don't think Broner should be on such a list. Lots of fighters today and in the past had a better defense than Broner. He gets hit fairly often and he has not fought the best fighters yet.

[BUNGALOWS]

You have a point but I guess the reason I'd pick Floyd is cause he's more of a defense first type guy. He's more defensively minded in a way.

Floyd might not be the best inside fighter but he can defend himself on the inside without clinching too.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Yeah, I can see where you're coming from. Thanks for not being a full blown Floyd tard. MUCH easier to discuss boxing topics when it pertains to Floyd.

Good Lord, some of these guys need to take the Floyd stick out of their ass.