Who had better defense, Floyd Mayweather Jr, SRL, Whitaker, Broner?

[BoxingFollower]

I think people are not taking in to thought how GREAT of a counter puncher and how great SRL moved, dude only got caught cleanly when he wanted to ****, otherwise up on his toes and dancing around the ring he was untouchable.

SRL was almost impossible to hit while moving around.

[DLT]

Ummmm newsflash **** rider. No one credible has Floyd over Sweet Pea in the defense department besides some Floyd ****riders on NSB. Get that through your head.

The reason why they're synonymous with defense is because people with 2 eyes got to see them fight in their primes.

dude, you make kid arguments. Im a grown man. Only lil boys say things like **** riders, nuthuggers, etc......

If you cant address me as a man then do me a favor and dont address. Ill debate with real boxing fans who can make arguments without slining names. Its childish. Whats wrong, you cant make your point without throwing out weak shots because someone disagrees with you? So many lil boys on this site nowdays. Its nothing like before

[DLT]

I think people are not taking in to thought how GREAT of a counter puncher and how great SRL moved, dude only got caught cleanly when he wanted to ****, otherwise up on his toes and dancing around the ring he was untouchable.

SRL was almost impossible to hit while moving around.

Leonards D was beast and better than 99% in history but Floyd & Pea are maybe the 2 best. Nothing wrong with coming behind them

[BoxingFollower]

Boner goes life and death vs Ponce and Malignaggi yet he's on these kinds of lists smh. Then you guys get mad when we say he's overrated. You guys are something else.

That's the whole reason, people talk about him related to defense all the time, so I put him on the list, gotta have something for the kiddies

[BUNGALOWS]

prime Oscar? He had just turned 24. I guess broner will be in his prime in his next fight. Pea also had a ton of fights at WW when he fought Oscar who was in his 1st WW fight. Meanwhile Floyd was in his 5th divsion when he fought Oscar, didnt weigh anywhere near the limit while Oscar had fought at MW. Floyd at that time was still basically a 140 pounder in size.

Pea was 29 and in his prime against Chavez who was also having his 1st fight at WW. Meanwhile Floyd was just turning 25 against JLC and making his LW debut while JLC was a super huge LW and had been there forever.

Your compariisons are horrible but expected. What happend against Zab? He didnt come close to winning a round after the 4th. He was shutout the last 8 rounds and wouldve been that way from the jump if he were a righty. Again, being a Southpaw is a huge advantage. Ask your boy Lucas about that with this shot version of Zab & Devon

LMAO. Semantics at it's finest. A 24 year old ODLHYA was looked upon as the favorite in that fight, and Pernell was well past prime at that point, but of course you won't bring that up.

doesn't matter which division. It just shows you how he'd deal with a guy like Oscar. Keep getting hit continuously to the body, and get hit with clean jabs.

Pea's victory over a prime Chaves >>>>> anything Floyd's done in his career.

What happened against Zab was him getting tagged in the early rounds. Using his gloves and arms to block. Pea did it the hard way. Using his head and body. Floyd's philly shell allows him to be more stationary, but also very hittable to the body.

Pea wins.

[BoxingFollower]

Leonards D was beast and better than 99% in history but Floyd & Pea are maybe the 2 best. Nothing wrong with coming behind them

I see your point.

[BUNGALOWS]

I'm Floyd's #1 **** rider.

I'd debate you like you were a grown man if you weren't on another grown man's ****. It's quite sad if ya ask me.

And you're not the average Floyd **** rider, you're his ultimate **** rider. It's creepy bro. Get a life, besides defending Floyd at all costs.

I've seen you in some threads where I was thinking to myself, "I think he would literally kill for Floyd." LMAO.

[Gatling]

LMAO. Semantics at it's finest. A 24 year old ODLHYA was looked upon as the favorite in that fight, and Pernell was well past prime at that point, but of course you won't bring that up.

doesn't matter which division. It just shows you how he'd deal with a guy like Oscar. Keep getting hit continuously to the body, and get hit with clean jabs.

Pea's victory over a prime Chaves >>>>> anything Floyd's done in his career.

What happened against Zab was him getting tagged in the early rounds. Using his gloves and arms to block. Pea did it the hard way. Using his head and body. Floyd's philly shell allows him to be more stationary, but also very hittable to the body.

Pea wins.

Whitaker was still rated top 1-2 P4P fighting DLH, he was hardly being overlooked.

Whitaker was not fighting a prime Chavez either. It was at a catchweight above JWW where Chavez had never fought before.

[Khalid X]

You guys are brain dead if you think Floyd's more verastyle.

Transition from offense to defense hands down goes to Pernell.

The man stayed in the pocket with you, and made you miss like no other. When he's on the outside, it's slip and rip.

More versatyle? How so? Pernell is just as versatile as Floyd, and better at most aspects.

The fact that I can problem count on one hand the times someone has landed a flush power shot on Floyd says it all.

[BUNGALOWS]

Whitaker was still rated top 1-2 P4P fighting DLH, he was hardly being overlooked.

Whitaker was not fighting a prime Chavez either. It was at a catchweight above JWW where Chavez had never fought before.

That's all semantics. Floyd was p4p against an OLD ODLHYA.

Pea's victory over Chaves, regardless of the circumstances was better than anything on Floyd's resume. Don't rewrite history, and make it seem like Chaves was a bum at the time. Please don't.