Has Mayweather a more important victory than Rigo over Nonito???

[Szef]

I thought that Donaire's comp had been pathetic for the last few fights and that he has shown flaws? We were reminded about that every day by clowns like you. Then when your favorite boxer beats Donaire, now Donaire is put on this pedestal as an all time great. Boxing fans tried to show you how you appreciate all boxers, but you along with a lot of you just like to pick and choose the ones that you like. Don't worry, you are in sorry company with a lot of posters who think like you.

Only in your delusional mind, Donaire was hyped here that's for sure but I never said he's not great I just always thought he fought guys who were perfect for him, stylewise. Donaire is a great fighter, he was just outclassed by a much better fighter. Comprende? Now put on your TMT shirt and ********** to Floyd's picture

He's mad, lmao! He's trying to hide it, but he's mad...lol. He isn't a Matthysee fan. He's a Pac fan in disguise.

Do I really need to bump your "Why Peterson will beat Matthysse" ,or something like that, thread? Get lost ****head

[UTEP]

ahh, poor fwanky

[Deevel916]

All the ATG"s have signature wins over other elite fighters except Floyd.

Ali holds wins over Foreman and Fraizer

Duran holds a win over a prime SRL

SRL holds wins over Hearns and Duran

Hopkins holds wins over a prime Trinidad, ODLH, Kelly Pavlik, Pascal, Tarver, W. Wright.

Tyson's signature win was over the undisputed HW champ Michael Spinks

RJJ holds a win over a 44-0 James toney although he could have taken on much better comp during his prime.

Future ATG Manny Pacquiao has wins over the 3 mexican greats (Barrera, JMM, Erik Morales) of our time, in addition to Cotto, Hatton, Margarito, Tim Bradley (yes he was robbed against Bradley).

Floyd's signature win/s came 12yrs ago against Corrales who though good wasnt a great fighter. His other signature win came against Ricky Hatton who arguably lost to Collazo. Could have secured himself as a top 5 ATG had he faced and beaten a prime Shane, Cotto, and Pacquiao.

[The Big Dunn]

All the ATG"s have signature wins over other elite fighters except Floyd.

Ali holds wins over Foreman and Fraizer

Duran holds a win over a prime SRL

SRL holds wins over Hearns and Duran

Hopkins holds wins over a prime Trinidad, ODLH, Kelly Pavlik, Pascal, Tarver, W. Wright.

Tyson's signature win was over the undisputed HW champ Michael Spinks

RJJ holds a win over a 44-0 James toney although he could have taken on much better comp during his prime.

Future ATG Manny Pacquiao has wins over the 3 mexican greats (Barrera, JMM, Erik Morales) of our time, in addition to Cotto, Hatton, Margarito, Tim Bradley (yes he was robbed against Bradley).

Floyd's signature win/s came 12yrs ago against Corrales who though good wasnt a great fighter. His other signature win came against Ricky Hatton who arguably lost to Collazo. Could have secured himself as a top 5 ATG had he faced and beaten a prime Shane, Cotto, and Pacquiao.

Please explain how beating erik morales counts as great when the fight before that he lost to zahir raheem? And 151 LB margs? Geez its like you elevate mannys wins but totally discount anything floyd did. You say manny beat bradley (I agree) but prime jmm was a draw and thge majority thought manny lost the next 2. You kinda left out the castillo wins too.

That's just a little inconsistent.

[DannYankee]

Well short answer no because he never went against a fighter that everyone thought oh **** the odds are stacked against you big time never on their prime . When was the last time you saw a Floyd fight and though oh man this could go either way! Not never.

[Marvellous1]

Well short answer no because he never went against a fighter that everyone thought oh **** the odds are stacked against you big time never on their prime . When was the last time you saw a Floyd fight and though oh man this could go either way! Not never.

To be honest, that's a little difficult when you've been considered the best in the sport for years and very few in or around your division are near your level.

You could apply that to the last 15+ of Wlad Klitscko's las fights.

You're basically complaining that he's too good, right?

[The Big Dunn]

To be honest, that's a little difficult when you've been considered the best in the sport for years and very few in or around your division are near your level.

You could apply that to the last 15+ of Wlad Klitscko's las fights.

You're basically complaining that he's too good, right?

He's really complaining that in every fight that was supposed to be close- castillo 2, corrales, mosley, and hatton- floyd beat that ass with ease.

[flat1985]

The Castillo & Corrales wins are both better then the Donaire win

[ballzhog]

To be honest, that's a little difficult when you've been considered the best in the sport for years and very few in or around your division are near your level.

You could apply that to the last 15+ of Wlad Klitscko's las fights.

You're basically complaining that he's too good, right?

I think the complaint he said there was that out of the 4 fighters that we all thought had a legit chance over the years (not Hatton hype), he fought about 0 of them, well maybe Cotto is the one but about 4 years and a "retirement"too late.

[Cardinal Buck]

Why who did he beat at those weights?
118 - Narvaez & Montiel
115 - Concepcion?

He hardly had any fights at those weights & the only decent win off the top of my head is Montiel.

He didn't clear any of those weight divisions, he cleared 122 as Mares went up in weight and Rigo was the only one left.

Vic was his best win and montiel was 2nd. I'm not impressed with his 122 resume and never agreed w the foy status