Has Mayweather a more important victory than Rigo over Nonito???

[Frank Ducketts]

With this I not say that Rigo is better P4P or something else. But Nonito is a Champion in 4 weigh classes, their only loss came at the age of 18, 12 years ago. He is in his prime, future hall of fame and beat all the best fighters of the divitions exept Mares because his promoters. I think not only Mayweather, if not the only two fighters who have defeated a rival that level are under equal conditions are Marquez and Pacquiao between them

I'm wrong????

Floyd has a bunch of those. Rigo has years to reach Floyd's status and many more victories like this.

[Frank Ducketts]

Corrales was his last Great win.

After that he fought past prime greats.

He could have achieved greatness in 07/08 but he chose to "retire"

You have got to be talking about Matthysse.

[SoulByThePound]

Rigondeaux went into the fight as a big underdog with a lot of people expecting him to lose. Had he lost he would have been written off as a nobody but the win has elevated him where he is considered one of the very top boxers skill wise. I don't think Mayweather has ever entered a fight with those type of circumstances. Career wise I don't think anything on Mayweather's resume was as important.

let HBO announcers and bert sugar tell it..this is mayweathers biggest test then they flip flop in anger after he wins

[Frank Ducketts]

Today's boxing fan is clueless about the sport. They so badly want to find a category that they can pick someone over Floyd in. They say Flyd always wins the fantasy fights, but he loses them too. And when you see the same ole posters/rejects criticizing Floyd...probably to get a rise out of his fans more than anything posting about Floyd's greatness, Floyd was never great. That's ok. Floyd has more fans who appreciate him now than ever before. Dlh left Arum, and became big, and Floyd has done the same. Karma

[UTEP]

You have got to be talking about Matthysse.

Nope.

Matthysse didn't "retire" in 07/08 to avoid prime Cotto, Margarito, and Paul Williams.

[damit305]

Oscar was as an important win for Money in terms of what it did for his career, that is, increase relevance. However if Mayweather would have lost to DLH it wouldn't have had thrown him into obscurity like a loss for Rigo vs Donaire

[SoulByThePound]

Nope.

Matthysse didn't "retire" in 07/08 to avoid prime Cotto, Margarito, and Paul Williams.

well cotto said himself he didnt truly pursue a fight with FMW. And thelikelyhood of that fight being made in 08 is slim.. TR vs GB but your a idiot anyway!

and the only top welter to face paul was Margarito not cotto..

[Szef]

Nope, Corrales is Floyd's greatest win, but Donaire was TOP 5 P4P fighter, undefeated for 10 years and was (and still is) considered as one of the most dangerous fighters in the game. Rigo totally outclassed him and that was his 12 fight as a pro...
Floyd is not even close

[UTEP]

well cotto said himself he didnt truly pursue a fight with FMW. And the likelyhood of that fight being made in 08 is slim.. TR vs GB but your a idiot anyway!

and the only top welter to face paul was Margarito not cotto..

Floyd was in "retirement" in 08 genius.

[Frank Ducketts]

Nope.

Matthysse didn't "retire" in 07/08 to avoid prime Cotto, Margarito, and Paul Williams.

Neither did Floyd.