Has Mayweather a more important victory than Rigo over Nonito???

[nachorjj]

With this I not say that Rigo is better P4P or something else. But Nonito is a Champion in 4 weigh classes, their only loss came at the age of 18, 12 years ago. He is in his prime, future hall of fame and beat all the best fighters of the divitions exept Mares because his promoters. I think not only Mayweather, if not the only two fighters who have defeated a rival that level are under equal conditions are Marquez and Pacquiao between them

I'm wrong????

[dan_cov]

No he hasn't though I don't feel Donaire was or is as good as he was being made out to be I can not take his achievements away from him.

Rigondeaux not only beating Donaire but the manner he did it may well be just the finest win of the last decade and the scary part is I'm pretty confident when I say we still haven't seen the best of Rigondeaux the problem is who the hell can bring it out of him?

[UTEP]

Corrales was his last Great win.

After that he fought past prime greats.

He could have achieved greatness in 07/08 but he chose to "retire"

[Cubanborn87]

nope not even close

[nachorjj]

Corrales was his last Great win.

After that he fought past prime greats.

He could have achieved greatness in 07/08 but he chose to "retire"

And prime Corrales is better than Nonito in your opinion????

[UTEP]

And prime Corrales is better than Nonito in your opinion????

Corrales has better wins on his resume.

Casamayor, Castillo, Freitas > Vic Darchinyan and Fernando Montiel.

[bojangles1987]

Corrales was his last Great win.

After that he fought past prime greats.

He could have achieved greatness in 07/08 but he chose to "retire"

Castillo 2 was his last great win IMO.

As long as Donaire doesn't suddenly descend into mediocrity, I really don't think Mayweather has a win that compares.

[nachorjj]

Corrales has better wins on his resume.

Casamayor, Castillo, Freitas > Vic Darchinyan and Fernando Montiel.

When Floyd beat Corrales, Corrales had not fought against this 3

[UTEP]

Castillo 2 was his last great win IMO.

As long as Donaire doesn't suddenly descend into mediocrity, I really don't think Mayweather has a win that compares.

Yea you're right Castillo 2 was a great win for Floyd too.

[UTEP]

When Floyd beat Corrales, Corrales had not fought against this 3

True.....Corrales really didn't have any great wins before he fought Floyd.