Originally posted by ailicec
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Comments Thread For: Team Canelo: All Opponents Must Face Us at 154
Collapse
-
-
Originally posted by Triumph 916 View PostHe only won a paper title against I guy that didn't belong in the convo @ a CW...and wasn't there a re-hydration clause is that fight? Fought Cotto at a CW...but this isn't about Pac.
I have no problem with the fight happening at 154...I do have a problem with a young kid having one legit fight at 154 and thinking he doesn't have to bend if asked to. I also have an issue with with 171 on fight against a guy who makes guest appearances at 154. He won a title there...doesn't mean he campaigns there. Did you expect RJJ to fight Lennox?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Triumph 916 View PostHe only won a paper title against I guy that didn't belong in the convo @ a CW...and wasn't there a re-hydration clause is that fight? Fought Cotto at a CW...but this isn't about Pac.
I have no problem with the fight happening at 154...I do have a problem with a young kid having one legit fight at 154 and thinking he doesn't have to bend if asked to. I also have an issue with with 171 on fight against a guy who makes guest appearances at 154. He won a title there...doesn't mean he campaigns there. Did you expect RJJ to fight Lennox?
There's no bending, the guy is Ring champ who cannot make 147 or 150 even. Where else is he supposed to fight? If he wants to move up, by all means, but he just won the real title. 172 is not that crazy at SWW, hell Trout was 171. I bet Angulo, Kirkland, Andrade are in the neighborhood. There's welters that put that much or more: Ortiz, Marg, Clottey. Bradley was just 160 fight night etc.
Comment
-
Originally posted by budfr View PostIts JMM 's fault but then again if Floyd thinks he is the best why doesn't he put on the weight to fight at 154 if canelo is supposed to be overhyped?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Davis40 View PostLOL Yeah thats the same thing
These guys pick who their going to risk it all for when moving up...Floyd did it for Oscar, Shane did it for Oscar etc...
Comment
-
Originally posted by HeroBando View PostNo rehydration clause that I know of. It'd be silly to set it at 15lbs anyway.
There's no bending, the guy is Ring champ who cannot make 147 or 150 even. Where else is he supposed to fight? If he wants to move up, by all means, but he just won the real title. 172 is not that crazy at SWW, hell Trout was 171. I bet Angulo, Kirkland, Andrade are in the neighborhood. There's welters that put that much or more: Ortiz, Marg, Clottey. Bradley was just 160 fight night etc.
And to piggy back off all the other names you mentioned...how did you feel about Broner at 130/135 size wise? Fair or cmon dude, move up and fight ppl your size?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Triumph 916 View PostWhat I'm implying is...did anybody really expect RJJ to fight the best HW in the division or was it ok that it was a match up a little more favorable to him...or was he ducking the top guys?
These guys pick who their going to risk it all for when moving up...Floyd did it for Oscar, Shane did it for Oscar etc...
You saw how much smaller JMM looked vs Floyd. If JMM can fight top guys at welter, his 5th division, why can't the bigger, younger, faster, more talented Floyd fight 1 division up from JMM, his 5th? A shot Mosley, Ndou,, Josesito had no fear of getting hurt by Canelo at 154. Neither does Matthysse, he just said it
Comment
-
Originally posted by Triumph 916 View PostI agree with it being at 154 but like I said...Nelo needs to STFU because he's the chasing a guy who may hold a title but size wise doesn't need to be there especially when he'll be facing a light HW come fight night.
And to piggy back off all the other names you mentioned...how did you feel about Broner at 130/135 size wise? Fair or cmon dude, move up and fight ppl your size?
Comment
-
Originally posted by HeroBando View PostEverybody knew Jones was a paper champ at HW. He was never the top ranked guy in the division, nor did he sit on that belt. It was a vanity belt for him. It'd be like Floyd snatching a belt of Stieglitz or something, not fighting a fellow champ in his 5th division, where he's 2x champ and #1.
You saw how much smaller JMM looked vs Floyd. If JMM can fight top guys at welter, his 5th division, why can't the bigger, younger, faster, more talented Floyd fight 1 division up from JMM, his 5th? A shot Mosley, Ndou,, Josesito had no fear of getting hurt by Canelo at 154. Neither does Matthysse, he just said it
Comment
Comment