Donaire and Cotto

[4Corners]

Cotto was robbed of a few more prime years by Margarito though. Instead of being past prime-still pretty good, which I think he is now, he probably wouldn't have hit this point in his career until a few years from now.

[$coinblatt$]

Cotto's never been iced in recent memory + wasn't Cotto Pacquiao's best win till date?

yeah, a knee quitter being Pacquiao's best win. LOL

Marco Antonio Barrera is Pacquiao's best win.

[Hiei]

yeah, a knee quitter being Pacquiao's best win. LOL

Marco Antonio Barrera is Pacquiao's best win.

Or his wins over Marquez and Morales

[thuggery]

Donaire by MILES.

[Puya]

who's the better fighter?

I will like to see this thread when Nonito starts to loose because once a boxer looses his prime or starts loosing because they are too high for their weight you people here start to put down previous achievements of a boxer.

For example:

Cotto
Morales
Trinidad
RJJ
etc

[Puya]

Two completely different fighters, don't see how one could compare one to the other. Donaire struggled to do what Cotto would have easily done, which was cut off the ring against Mathebula and Narvaez, Miguel is obviously the better pressure fighter, infighter, body puncher, cuts off the ring a lot better as well. Donaire is the better counter puncher, more devastating puncher P4P, and has better stamina.

[Slyboots]

Cotto. Donaire has some amazing natural talent, but Cotto's higher ring IQ and boxing ability makes him the better fighter, IMO.

I don't know why I even bother to make a serious reply to this thread, it's filled with the usual NSB Mexi****s who don't like PRs.

[Angelo89]

This is a no brainer, when Cotto fought anybody good he lost. Donaire is clearly better.

[MartinC]

Donaires better now. Cotto has not been the same since plasterito and Manny beat him.

[El Angel]

Prime for prime? Prime Cotto could beat the same class of fighters Donaire has beaten in his prime.