Donaire and Cotto

[Bob Boss Monies]

Cotto's never been iced

He never beat Pacquiao or fought Marquez four times either..

[Doctor_Tenma]

Two completely different fighters, don't see how one could compare one to the other. Donaire struggled to do what Cotto would have easily done, which was cut off the ring against Mathebula and Narvaez, Miguel is obviously the better pressure fighter, infighter, body puncher, cuts off the ring a lot better as well. Donaire is the better counter puncher, more devastating puncher P4P, and has better stamina.

[Snake...]

Donaire is winning this poll easily

also for the people who are saying ''Cotto's never been iced'' he quit 2x

and Duran got ''Iced'' by Hearns but does that make Cotto better?

[AP♠]

TS doesn't know what iced means SMH

[Doctor_Tenma]

I see one question asking who's better, and the poll being about who's greater, in that case Donaire is greater.

[codey]

Donaire easily hands down, I dont see donaire taking a knee and quitting without a single punch being landed, check out my sig for proof.

Quitto ****d his weak countrymen loyalty for as long as he can, its over!

Dude. why the hate? you would never understand what it takes to be a fighter! you don't respect the sport man. unfortunately!! it takes a different kinda cojonos to climb up on that ring and **** it out with a rival for 12Rds.

these men train countless hours at the gym, miss out on family time with there loved ones and have to be on strict diets. it's a hardknock life man, but yet these fighters do what they gotta do to feed there family, and not to mention give there fans a good fight. Boxers deserve all the respect in the world regardless of their ethnic origin. it's a crude sport man. please have some decency.

[KickAzz]

don't think Cotto was ever top 4 p4p

[Bushbaby]

Cotto is one of the most overhyped fighters in recent memory

LOL dis guy.

Donaire is the better fighter. But Cotto did get a lot of years taken away from the cheater and total scumbag Antonio Margarito.

[Bushbaby]

Dude. why the hate? you would never understand what it takes to be a fighter! you don't respect the sport man. unfortunately!! it takes a different kinda cojonos to climb up on that ring and **** it out with a rival for 12Rds.

these men train countless hours at the gym, miss out on family time with there loved ones and have to be on strict diets. it's a hardknock life man, but yet these fighters do what they gotta do to feed there family, and not to mention give there fans a good fight. Boxers deserve all the respect in the world regardless of their ethnic origin. it's a crude sport man. please have some decency.

You're asking a racist why he hates on Puerto Rican fighters??

[4Corners]

Donaire is much much more talented than Cotto, and is fairly similar resume wise right now.

Cotto's beaten Paulie, Torres, Quintana, Judah, Mosley, Clottey, Foreman, and Margarito.

Donaire's beaten Darchinyan, Mthalane, H. Marquez, Montiel, Mathebula, and Nishioka.

I think when it's all said and done, both will be in the Hall of Fame, though I think Donaire will be a 100% hall of fame fighter, while Cotto to me is borderline. I think Donaire could be an ATG.