If Donaire beats Rigo, he's p4p #1

[Pacdbest]

How does that qualify him for P4P? And if he beats Rigo I'd say MAYBE 2 or 3 not #1.

Doanire Beating Rigo was like Pac beating Floyd! Floyd wont even walk inside the Ring with Pac. That's 1 & 2 in the division. Floyd's always fighting the no 3-9 spot. Avoiding no 2!

Donaire hasn't lost in 12 yrs, 3 div champ, 2 KOTY, I rate him already as the 2nd in ATG Pinoy Boxing. He already surpases Ellorde!

[letsgobrady]

IF he beats Rigondeaux who most boxing fans wanted to see him fight.

yes rigondeaux is the only fighter that fans wanted to see donaire fight that he is going to fight and even that fight kinda seemed forced so how could you knock other fighters for not fighting anyone the fans want to see them fight when donaire has not really fought anyone that the fans wanted to see him fight

[letsgobrady]

I think Rigo will win too, but if Donaire pulls it off he deserves serious credit.

he does deserve credit for beating rigo but im not sure if that should make him the #1 fighter in the world but its all oppinion any way so if you wanna put donaire #1 right now hey why not its your oppinion

[Pacdbest]

yes rigondeaux is the only fighter that fans wanted to see donaire fight that he is going to fight and even that fight kinda seemed forced so how could you knock other fighters for not fighting anyone the fans want to see them fight when donaire has not really fought anyone that the fans wanted to see him fight

Donaire ran out challenger that he has to take Rigo with 11 wins. He'll move up next to 126 and already named John, Juanma & Gamboa! That's cream of the top again!

[dan_cov]

I think Rigo will win too, but if Donaire pulls it off he deserves serious credit.

IF he pulls it off he will get serious credit from me. No doubt hes in the top 3 p4p for me.

People need to realise Rigondeaux isn't just a pro with 11 fights, this guy has always had a pro style and destroyed everything in his path for a decade fighting week in, week out. He is in my mind an elite level talent and I personally feel he has the style to make Donaire look ridiculous. He has some frightening tools.

If Donaire wins (I can't see it though I do give him a punchers chance & it sure isn't because Rigo has a bad chin) I'll hold my hands up and be the first to say, this guy is for real. I think Donaire is good, no doubt, maybe even the 2nd best at 122 & south of and would beat almost everyone at 126 but for me I'm convinced Rigondeaux is something else & will show it on the 14th.

[letsgobrady]

Donaire ran out challenger that he has to take Rigo with 11 wins. He'll move up next to 126 and already named John, Juanma & Gamboa! That's cream of the top again!

people were asking to see a fight against rigo before he even fought vasquez the only fight people were asking for was rigo and mares and how does he get credit for fights he has not had yet (john,juanma and gamboa)

[Bermuda]

i'd have him at #2 but a strong argument could be made for him being #1....

[thuggery]

P4P lists are just opinions. The only one that really mattered was Golden Boy owned Ring Magazine rankings but it's an utter joke now.

Marquez
Donaire
Ward
Sergio
Wlad

Place them in any order you wish. No points for inactivity or cherry picking.

[HanzGruber]

beating old a$s nishioka and arce, an unknown mathebula and 20 fight no amateur experience vasquez does not mean alot. Beating rigo might move him up a spot but not #1

[Joey_Torreo]

Just wanna add, Floyd is obviously the most skilled boxer in the world but fights once a year and against guys no one really cares to see.

Ward is a skillful guy but none of his wins would be better than Rigo nor is his division as good (1 weight champ too)

Martinez knocks out a lot of guys like Donaire but again the competition isn't as good as some of the guys Donaire has fought.

Marquez great fighter but besides Pac KO (yes huge win), hasn't been doing much

Ima have to disagree with your argument on ward. Wouldn't his win over froch equate or beat donaires victory over rigo ( if it happens ) I mean the fight with froch pitted 1 vs 2 of the smw division