If Donaire beats Rigo, he's p4p #1

[Hiei]

no.................

[wizard king]

Donaire was already on P4P list since 2007 after he Ko Darchinyan. Since then how many fights does Floyd has? How many Ducks? How many Vacations?

Still doest make donaire close to being number 1 and even after this fight he would be 5 or 4

[F l i c k e r]

In short, no.

Nonito will have to do more to get #1. Top 5? Okay but not numero uno.

[Angelo89]

Rigondeaux is the toughest opponent Donaire can fight so if he beats him, he will solidfy his place on the #1 spot on the P4P list. Floid barely fights and doesn't even fight the best, he's overrated and lost to Castillo and Ortiz was about to beat him before Floid cheap-shotted him.

[Daddy T]

I don't think floyd deserves to be number 1 any more. p4p should be current not what you did a couple of years ago.

I think ward is the best p4p right now floyd 2 (but this is based more off past glories than current ability ... I mean how can beating guerrero be better than beating say, chavez, pacquiao, rigo, etc)

marquez, martinez and donaire (if he wins) have to round out the top 5 not sure of order

[Pacdbest]

Still doest make donaire close to being number 1 and even after this fight he would be 5 or 4

Ok let's only compare Donaire & Floyd's resume from 2007 when Donaire came into scene!

Donaire, 14 - 0 - 10 KO all championship, 3 were undefeated, Montiel, Dachinyan were top P4P. 2 KOTY, 1 FOTY. fought in 4 div, 112, 115, 118, 122.

Floyd 6-0 -1KO, Got the KO by cheating, 1 undefeated, NO KOTY, 1 FOTY. Fought in 2 div 147 & 154.


We are talking P4P, It's easily Donaire by numbers!

And u hear Max Kellerman's argument, what If Donaire's 147 lbs. or 160, or 168, he'll be rated higher than Floyd, Martinez or WArd!

[Motofan]

Ward........

[controlmachete]

He should be!! Those last 5 were cream of the crop at the lower weight class. Don't mention Mares, Donaire don't really need that fight. If it happens, it will be like montiel/Arce fight. easy KO!!

Floyd just fought 2 pac sparring partners & 1 Pac leftover in almost 3 yrs!

lmao!

[controlmachete]

Donaire ran out challenger that he has to take Rigo with 11 wins. He'll move up next to 126 and already named John, Juanma & Gamboa! That's cream of the top again!

those two cream of the top?? lol, and gamboa? lets see how he fares once hes not in the juice, he was in the list of that ped guy

[Angelo89]

Ok let's only compare Donaire & Floyd's resume from 2007 when Donaire came into scene!

Donaire, 14 - 0 - 10 KO all championship, 3 were undefeated, Montiel, Dachinyan were top P4P. 2 KOTY, 1 FOTY. fought in 4 div, 112, 115, 118, 122.

Floyd 6-0 -1KO, Got the KO by cheating, 1 undefeated, NO KOTY, 1 FOTY. Fought in 2 div 147 & 154.


We are talking P4P, It's easily Donaire by numbers!

And u hear Max Kellerman's argument, what If Donaire's 147 lbs. or 160, or 168, he'll be rated higher than Floyd, Martinez or WArd!

Great post bro, Floid is a paper champ and doesn't even fight anybody that's any good. Donaire fights the best and will prove it on April 13!