If Donaire beats Rigo, he's p4p #1

[RichCCFC]

Agree or disagree?

- Would have beat the best fighter in his division
- 4 weight champion
- FOTY last year with 4 fights (crazy)
- Takes year round drug testing (only fighter in the sport to do so)

[Pacdbest]

Agree or disagree?

- Would have beat the best fighter in his division
- 4 weight champion
- FOTY last year with 4 fights (crazy)
- Takes year round drug testing (only fighter in the sport to do so)

He should be!! Those last 5 were cream of the crop at the lower weight class. Don't mention Mares, Donaire don't really need that fight. If it happens, it will be like montiel/Arce fight. easy KO!!

Floyd just fought 2 pac sparring partners & 1 Pac leftover in almost 3 yrs!

[Angelo89]

Agree or disagree?

- Would have beat the best fighter in his division
- 4 weight champion
- FOTY last year with 4 fights (crazy)
- Takes year round drug testing (only fighter in the sport to do so)

Agree 100%, I actually have him #1 P4P right now but if he wins it will further solidify his place as the #1 Fighter. He's also the only athlete to do 24/7 year round drug testing which deserves major props. Guillermo Rigodneaux proclaims himself as the greatest boxer in history so if Donaire beats him, then Nonito will be in the dicussion for G.O.A.T. Boxer.

[Doctor_Tenma]

In short, hell no. He'll move into the number 4 spot on my list.

[The Big Dunn]

Agree or disagree?

- Would have beat the best fighter in his division
- 4 weight champion
- FOTY last year with 4 fights (crazy)
- Takes year round drug testing (only fighter in the sport to do so)

disagree- floyd, ward, sergio, have not lost in a while and, with all due respect to Nonito, each has a win or wins during their winning streaks that are better than a Rigo is.

[RichCCFC]

Just wanna add, Floyd is obviously the most skilled boxer in the world but fights once a year and against guys no one really cares to see.

Ward is a skillful guy but none of his wins would be better than Rigo nor is his division as good (1 weight champ too)

Martinez knocks out a lot of guys like Donaire but again the competition isn't as good as some of the guys Donaire has fought.

Marquez great fighter but besides Pac KO (yes huge win), hasn't been doing much

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Agree or disagree?

- Would have beat the best fighter in his division
- 4 weight champion
- FOTY last year with 4 fights (crazy)
- Takes year round drug testing (only fighter in the sport to do so)

How does that qualify him for P4P? And if he beats Rigo I'd say MAYBE 2 or 3 not #1.

[RichCCFC]

disagree- floyd, ward, sergio, have not lost in a while and, with all due respect to Nonito, each has a win or wins during their winning streaks that are better than a Rigo is.

Guess we have to disagree, Rigondeaux is an amazing fighter and one of the top 5 in the world today (disregarding p4p accolades).

[Jloro]

Disagree. Beating the goat with 10 fights doesn't make you better than the others.
He'd still be like 4 or 5 which isn't bad

[STREET CLEANER]

Donaire has to beat mares to earn the #1 spot, not Rigo who is unproven till this point