Can we all agree, Lucas Matthysse should be undefeated?

[illmaticfighter]

He had a hard time with zab so hes not some god.

i think he should be undefeated but as much as zab gets called a gatekeeper its kinda funny how close that fight was.

[bojangles1987]

He had a hard time with zab so hes not some god.

i think he should be undefeated but as much as zab gets called a gatekeeper its kinda funny how close that fight was.

It was Matthysse's first fight on that stage, and he deserved to win the fight more. He didn't have a "hard time" with Judah as much as he fought too conservatively in his first big fight.

[Greg House]

He gave Devon a one-sided beating. There's no question about that one. He was robbed.

The fight with Zab was the first time he was facing that kind of competition and the first time fighting in the US. He didn't throw a lot in the first rounds but finished the fight with Zab begging for the end. Even though the fight was close because of him giving away some of the first couple of rounds, i still think that he won a clear decision. A win is a win, it doesnt have to be a "robbery" for people to think that the result was unfair. He should be undefeated.

Anyway, Lucas learnt a lot from those fights and now he starts the fights very diferently throwing a lot more punches. In a rematch i bet he would stop both of them.

[Greg House]

He gave Devon a one-sided beating. There's no question about that one. He was robbed.

The fight with Zab was the first time he was facing that kind of competition and the first time fighting in the US. He didn't throw a lot in the first rounds but finished the fight with Zab begging for the end. Even though the fight was close because of him giving away some of the first couple of rounds, i still think that he won a clear decision. A win is a win, it doesnt have to be a "robbery" for people to think that the result was unfair. He should be undefeated.

Anyway, Lucas learnt a lot from those fights and now he starts the fights very diferently throwing a lot more punches. In a rematch i bet he would stop both of them.

[Russian Crushin]

Last time someone made a thread about the fight, I watched it again and had it 7-4-1 for Matthysse. I thought there was a round or two that could be given to Judah to close the gap, give him the draw and Judah has a 1 point win.

There was also a KD so even with a 2 round swing, you still get a draw

[Master Splinter]

Yes, You sir are correct.

[oaklandstephen]

ummm no. he lost at least 8 rounds in the judah fight. he just did great in 2 of the 3 last rounds rounds. if i remember correctly judah out landed him in the 12th.

[teddycanyon]

he totally beat Alexander, but the Judah fight was close. That's the only reason I'm putting any stock in Judah's fight with Garcia if he was able to fight Matthysse close.

[Money_May]

No I don't agree. I had him losing 7 rounds to 5 against Judah. And due to the KD I had Judah by a point.

[SugarAnt05]

Nah, he started off way too slow against zab and he didnt dominate alexander, he did get the win imo.