Better wins: Mayweather over Castillo & Corrales or Ward over Kessler & Froch?????

[Kagami Taiga]

castillo was injured in the second fight

if only you knew the circumstances! then you would understand all the excuses I have to make for floyd!

Dude shut up and go stab some life sized joe calzaghe dolls.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I don't see how this is a question worth asking, Floyd obviously.

[Frank Ducketts]

In your opinion, which of these wins are better for each fighter???

To be honest, if Froch Ward was a 15 round fight, I dont know who wins. But I have to stick to reality. Floyds wins are better because he beat 2 big guys in style. Ward won two ugly fights...one of which he won where he was accused of fouling. Castillo beat a top pfp guy so that alone makes Floyds wins better for starters.

With that aside I love both guys but if Floyd and Ward were the same size, Floyd would beat Wards ass. I'm not sold on Ward yet because I'm not sold on his style of fighting. Ward is a tough guy no question, and has fought some stiff opposition, but I'm prejudiced against converted styles lol. Ward will be exposed. Will he win when he is exposed? The greats do. Froch imo started too late. Nobody has started too late against Floyd.

[Doctor_Tenma]

To be honest, if Froch Ward was a 15 round fight, I dont know who wins. But I have to stick to reality. Floyds wins are better because he beat 2 big guys in style. Ward won two ugly fights...one of which he won where he was accused of fouling. Castillo beat a top pfp guy so that alone makes Floyds wins better for starters.

With that aside I love both guys but if Floyd and Ward were the same size, Floyd would beat Wards ass. I'm not sold on Ward yet because I'm not sold on his style of fighting. Ward is a tough guy no question, and has fought some stiff opposition, but I'm prejudiced against converted styles lol. Ward will be exposed. Will he win when he is exposed? The greats do. Froch imo started too late. Nobody has started too late against Floyd.

That has no merit on anything, literally. Even if you used that for Chavez Jr-Martinez, if fights were 15 rounds fighters would change their approach and fight at a slower pace.

[Visceral]

I say Mayweather. But if you said Dawson and Froch, I would have a harder time choosing.

[Frank Ducketts]

That has no merit on anything, literally. Even if you used that for Chavez Jr-Martinez, if fights were 15 rounds fighters would change their approach and fight at a slower pace.

Read the next sentence after what you highlighted in bold print.

[-Lowkey-]

Ward's wins are more impressive to me don't know why this poll is so one sided.

Correct me if I'm wrong but Kessler was favourite to beat Ward, Ward thoroughly out classed Kessler and Froch.

Mayweather Castillo 1 was a close fight could have gone either way. Corrales I believe had issues making weight and was about to go to jail.

[-DSG-]

No way no how. Dawson was effected by the weight, he hadn't been there in 6 years, still a good win for Ward, but not what it could have been.

Corrales was #5 P4P, the man at 130, coming off good wins too.

Yeah but Chico was struggling with weight too he was 135 pound fighter draining to 130

[IronDanHamza]

Castillo and Corrales I would say.

It's reasonabley close but the edge goes to Mayweather.

It's sad that there are people who think Andre Ward has achieved what Mayweather has done is or closing in him. Mayweather's resume at 130 is better than Ward's resume.

[-DSG-]

Ward is the best p4p fighter and will be there for many years!