Better wins: Mayweather over Castillo & Corrales or Ward over Kessler & Froch?????

[4Corners]

It took him 2 fights to do it

Castillo is a damn good fighter though, and most people on here don't give him enough props. Even the Mexican fans don't give Castillo his due or carry his legacy on like other fighters on here.

Floyd was also injured in the first fight, and he clearly won the 2nd fight.

[Alx.]

about even i guess, slight edge to mayweather

[-DSG-]

Their all great wins I just like wards better

[Kagami Taiga]

It took him 2 fights to do it

If u knew the circumstances behind the fights and the fact that Floyd immediately rematched him when he really didn't have to, u wouldn't be factoring in the two fights it took.

[4Corners]

What also makes this a good question is that Floyd dominated Corrales as much as any fighter has ever dominated another Top 10 P4P fighter, it was a straight beat down. He did struggle with Castillo in the first fight, arguably may have lost the fight. He did beat him clearly in the rematch but did not dominate him by any means.

Ward didn't dominate Kessler or Froch in the manner that Floyd whupped Corrales, but he didn't struggle with either like Floyd did with Castillo. He did whup Kessler and Froch by wide margins.

I just think Castillo > Froch. Froch and Corrales are about equal in terms of quality for me. While Kessler is about equal to Genaro Hernandez.

[-PBP-]

Castillo and Corrales

[4Corners]

Castillo and Corrales

Not a Ray Leonard fan??? You skipped right over him in your sig homie.

[SkillspayBills]

Castillo Corrales for me. They were both top dogs of their division and Diego was on the P4P list when Floyd beat him.

[Gino Ros]

I said they're about even....but if you twisted my arm, I would say Floyd's wins because Castillo & Corrales are so much bigger than Floyd.

They were both basically welterweights when Floyd fought them.

[-DSG-]

What also makes this a good question is that Floyd dominated Corrales as much as any fighter has ever dominated another Top 10 P4P fighter, it was a straight beat down. He did struggle with Castillo in the first fight, arguably may have lost the fight. He did beat him clearly in the rematch but did not dominate him by any means.

Ward didn't dominate Kessler or Froch in the manner that Floyd whupped Corrales, but he didn't struggle with either like Floyd did with Castillo. He did whup Kessler and Froch by wide margins.

I just think Castillo > Froch. Froch and Corrales are about equal in terms of quality for me. While Kessler is about equal to Genaro Hernandez.

I say castillo and froch is even. I disagree I think froch is better than that corrales. I think Kessler was better than Hernandez.the Hernandez win for Floyd was impressive because Of how young Floyd was.