Better wins: Mayweather over Castillo & Corrales or Ward over Kessler & Froch?????

[4Corners]

In your opinion, which of these wins are better for each fighter???

[Kagami Taiga]

Yikes!!! Really good question.

[4Corners]

I think Castillo is greater as of right now than Carl Froch, just my opinion. Plus, Castillo was in his prime, Froch was still really good but I'm not sure if Froch was in his prime in 2011.

I think Ward over Froch is about equal right now to when Floyd beat Corrales, as far as a quality win. I'd rate Ward's win over Kessler about equal to Floyd's win over Genaro Hernandez, really good fighters and really good wins. But I feel Floyd's win Castillo takes him above these two for Ward.

[RubenSonny]

Not even close to be honest.

[Light_Speed]

Damn that's a tough one. I'll go with Floyd wins over Castillo and Corrales because one guy was undefeated and the other was a long time reigning champ. Yeah the first Castillo fight was close enough to go either way but Floyd was injured and proved it in the rematch. Also these wins were in two different divisions.

Kessler had already been outboxed before, he was the #1 SMW by default when Calzaghe retired. Froch got outboxed by Taylor before scoring a come from behind KO, and he got a gift against Dirrell. Two very good wins but not as good as Floyd's.

[-DSG-]

Ward over froch and Kessler

[-DSG-]

Floyd barely beat Castillo in the first fight

[Kagami Taiga]

Id probably go Mayweather's wins. Its tough tho. But corrales looked unbeatable before Floyd beat him and Castillo was the clear best fighter in the division when Floyd beat him as well and he did that on his first true fight in the division

[Kagami Taiga]

Floyd barely beat Castillo in the first fight

But he clearly beat him in the 2nd fight.

[-DSG-]

But he clearly beat him in the 2nd fight.

It took him 2 fights to do it