Better wins: Mayweather over Castillo & Corrales or Ward over Kessler & Froch?????

[-DSG-]

I also think wards destruction of Dawson was better than mayweathers destruction of corrales

[The Tase]

none of these fighters are true legit hall of famers.

[daggum]

If u knew the circumstances behind the fights and the fact that Floyd immediately rematched him when he really didn't have to, u wouldn't be factoring in the two fights it took.

castillo was injured in the second fight

if only you knew the circumstances! then you would understand all the excuses I have to make for floyd!

[4Corners]

I say castillo and froch is even. I disagree I think froch is better than that corrales. I think Kessler was better than Hernandez.the Hernandez win for Floyd was impressive because Of how young Floyd was.

Castillo has beat Johnston, Bazan, J. Diaz, Lazcano, Corrales, and Casamayor.

Froch has beat Pascal, Taylor, Dirrell, Abraham, Johnson, and Bute. He should have lost to Dirrell though, and Castillo arguably beat Floyd, which would be hands down greater than anything Froch has done so far. And Taylor/Johnson were far from what they had been and were on their way out from the top.

Froch still has a solid resume, but right now I'd take Castillo's over Froch.

Kessler has beat Mundine, Andrade, and Froch.

Genaro beat Nelson, Alexandrov, and C. Hernandez. Granted Nelson was past his best days, but he was still the man at 130 and Genaro beat him.

So for me Castillo edges Froch on having a better resume so far, and Genaro & Kessler have about the same quality of wins.

[4Corners]

I also think wards destruction of Dawson was better than mayweathers destruction of corrales

No way no how. Dawson was effected by the weight, he hadn't been there in 6 years, still a good win for Ward, but not what it could have been.

Corrales was #5 P4P, the man at 130, coming off good wins too.

[4Corners]

none of these fighters are true legit hall of famers.

No one was asking if you think Castillo, Corrales, Froch, or Kessler are HOF. The question was which two wins are better.

And based on who's gotten into the HOF, Castillo and Corrales could very well end up in. Tszyu got in the HOF on his first ballot, and his wins were R. Mayweather, Rodriguez, Pineda, Ruelas, Gonzalez, Mitchell, Urkal, Judah, Tackie, and Leija.

I'll take Castillo beating Johnston, Bazan, Lazcano, J. Diaz, Casamayor, Corrales, and arguably having a win over Floyd to be as good as that, if not better in terms of quality.

[-Kev-]

Castillo was The Ring 135 Champion, Corrales was a top 10 P4P undefeated fighter.


Neither Froch or Kessler were top 10 P4P fighters or Ring champions. They were both champions though, WBC and WBA respectively.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Kessler already got his ass whooped by Joke.

Froch already got his ass whooped by Dirrell.


Mayweather > Ward.

[daggum]

Kessler already got his ass whooped by Joke.

Froch already got his ass whooped by Dirrell.


Mayweather > Ward.

castillo got ko'd 4 times before floyd fought him! what an effing bum! and floyd lost to him! holy sh-it!

[FeFist]

Castillo and Coralles are better than wins over Froch and Kessler. It's not even close.