whose overall a better boxer, toney or floyd

[Cardinal Buck]

It would be really close if Floyd had blocks of cement on his feet.

[Boxing Bob]

TS has a Pac signature photo and he says Toney. Shocking!!!

[GTL]

When they are in top condition it is fairly close, but Floyd is always in top shape and Toney almost never is.

The truth.. Tony always had weight issues and loved food too much..
He didnt train around the clock my floyd did..

Toney was also extremely lazy.. both have the ability to make changes and adapt..

Id say floyd overall is a better boxer, but i liked toneys style much better.he stood right infront of you..

[ModernTalking]

Toney...health come last.

[IronDanHamza]

Mayweather IMO. By quite a margin.

But Toney was exceptional when he was on his A game.

[RightJab]

If one was white it'd be easier to decide i honestly, deeply feel.
On that basis i went for floyd, i think some white people do really enjoy his boxing accolades in secret tbh..... Toney always enjoyed/ enjoys burger, so still a stand up guy really.

[Frank Ducketts]

Mayweather IMO. By quite a margin.

But Toney was exceptional when he was on his A game.

I agree 1000% with this...

[Frank Ducketts]

i say toney.........

You've never seen Floyd outboxed. Toney has been outboxed. What does Toney do better than Floyd as a boxer?

[!! Shawn]

I'd say Floyd is better "overall" as in he has a more complete outside game than Toney ever did, but in terms of absolute fighting ability, I would put Toney a little bit higher up than Floyd.

Toneys inside game is WAYYYYYYYY better than Floyds though.

[Johnwoo8686]

I'd say Floyd is better "overall" as in he has a more complete outside game than Toney ever did, but in terms of absolute fighting ability, I would put Toney a little bit higher up than Floyd.

Toneys inside game is WAYYYYYYYY better than Floyds though.

There is no way that the bolded is true. Floyd is superior to Toney in almost everyway. He's better defensively, quicker, and sharper. He's also been able to beat inside fighters at their own game.