Meldrick Taylor vs Amir Khan at 140, who wins?

[BoxingGenius27]

Post-Chavez version of Taylor went up in weight and clearly defeated Aaron Davis.

Khan has never beaten anyone as good as Aaron Davis, nor has he fought at 147.

Besides Breland, who did Aaron Davis beat that was on the elite level before he lost to Taylor?

Never beaten anyone as good as Aaron Davis?

[Isaac Hunt]

Taylor was an exceptional fighter as was Chavez. Khan is lucky there are not fighters like them around today. Taylor would destroy Khan even he would have difficulty in coming out with excuses because it would be one sided.

[BoxingGenius27]

Saying Meldrick Taylor was the same after Chavez is like saying Roy was the same after Tarver because Roy beat Trinidad, Lacy, Shieka and Hanshaw.

[-PBP-]

Dude, why are you so bent on believing that post Chavez Taylor was still the same?

No he wasn't. He just wasn't. But for some reason every other thread you try to convince everyone he was. He wasn't.

And nobody brings up the fact that he struggled against Brown and Garcia post Chavez. Meldrick Taylor was never the same after that fight.

[MJ223]

Saying Meldrick Taylor was the same after Chavez is like saying Roy was the same after Tarver because Roy beat Trinidad, Lacy, Shieka and Hanshaw.

Taylor won another title AFTER Chavez.....

Did Roy AFTER Tarver???

[BoxingGenius27]

Taylor won another title AFTER Chavez.....

Did Roy AFTER Tarver???

You do know that his bouts with Shieka and Hanshaw were for the title right?

So to answer your question, yes, Roy won a title AFTER Tarver.

In your book and based off your standards, I guess that makes Roy legit post Tarver right?

Titles mean Jack schit. Just look at Canelo's title from Matthew Hatton.

[Thread Stealer]

Dude, why are you so bent on believing that post Chavez Taylor was still the same?

No he wasn't. He just wasn't. But for some reason every other thread you try to convince everyone he was. He wasn't.

I never said he was the same post-Chavez. I said he was still a good fighter for a couple years afterwards, certainly better than the overrated Khan.

[Isaac Hunt]

Saying Meldrick Taylor was the same after Chavez is like saying Roy was the same after Tarver because Roy beat Trinidad, Lacy, Shieka and Hanshaw.

I agree. I remember watching the fight live. It was a pivotal fight and Taylor was never quite himself after it. The post Chavez Taylor would be too much for Khan but the pre Chavez Taylor was a phenom.

[MJ223]

You do know that his bouts with Shieka and Hanshaw were for the title right?

So to answer your question, yes, Roy won a title AFTER Tarver.

In your book and based off your standards, I guess that makes Roy legit post Tarver right?

Titles mean Jack schit. Just look at Canelo's title from Matthew Hatton.

You know your reaching right???

[Poet682006]

Taylor also had a win over Glenwood Brown post-Chavez. It really wasn't until the Terry Norris fight that you could honestly say that Taylor was finished as a legit fighter.

Poet