Meldrick Taylor vs Amir Khan at 140, who wins?

[Ringlife]

Taylor win this by KO.

[Richard Wadd]

khan wins with his amazing defense, ring IQ, technical skills, and steel chin.

Who did Taylor ever beat? The lousy trainer buddy? 2 seconds from beating Chavez? Khan beat Maidana and Judah!

[LacedUp]

Voted Khan just because.

Taylor was alright - nothing more than that.

Besides - Khan is always a quick KO victim in these fantasy threads.

[Richard Wadd]

Voted Khan just because.

Taylor was alright - nothing more than that.

Besides - Khan is always a quick KO victim in these fantasy threads.

Alright fighters don't comprehensively beat buddy McGirt, come within 2 seconds of beating a 1990 Chavez, and then beat aaron Davis while being a spent force.

But khan would of win with his wonderful skills, intelligence and iron chin.

[LacedUp]

Alright fighters don't comprehensively beat buddy McGirt, come within 2 seconds of beating a 1990 Chavez, and then beat aaron Davis while being a spent force.

But khan would of win with his wonderful skills, intelligence and iron chin.

I'm not saying Taylor wouldn't beat Khan, and I don't think I ever said he was a spent force.

All I'm saying is that you can take any belt holder from the past and put him up against Khan and people will pick Khan to lose by KO.

[Thread Stealer]

Khan might beat the Taylor who fought Espana at 147. Any version before that beats Khan at 147. And 140 is no contest at all, Taylor was leagues better than Khan.

[BigAlexSand]

Taylor is quicker, stronger, and more skilled. I don't see any version of Khan beating a prime Talyor... Possibly the old beaten up Taylor would suffer a UD lose.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Taylor just overwhelms him with his seven and eight punch combinations and while Khan can hit, Taylor would be too tough. Taylor wears him down and knocks him out, with some good action in an entertaining fight.

[STREET CLEANER]

I actually think Khans smarter than Taylor. Also Khan stops Taylor.

It took a prime Chavez Sr to get a movie ending against Taylor in a fight that he was clearly losing.

I doubt that Khan can measure to that

[Thread Stealer]

It took a prime Chavez Sr to get a movie ending against Taylor in a fight that he was clearly losing.

I doubt that Khan can measure to that

Khan would not even be competitive with a 1990 version of Chavez.