So, im gonna be the one to ask, Cotto tonight vs Cotto from Pac fight....

[Bull24]

Watching the fight gave me more hope that Pacquiao can beat Mayweather! It was the same or a better Cotto that fought Pacquiao. This Cotto lost alot after the Pacman beating.

[Danieltapia]

Cotto was the same, just Mayweather is a carefull fighter without much power. I think Cotto hit Margs and Mayweather more than he did Manny though. I would like to see the punch stats from all the fights.

[boliodogs]

The question was which Cotto was better but all the written answers seem to be about could Cotto beat Pac at 154. I did not see the fight so I did not vote. I think people should realize that Cotto vs Pac at 154 is probably just a fantasy fight that will never happen. If Cotto has developed into a full sized junior middleweight that's great for him and he should stay at that weight. But Pacquiao is the same little guy he always was. He has not grown any bigger at age 33. He is still a big lightweight who weighs in at 144 or 145 after breakfast and lunch and fully hydrated. He already holds a KO win over Cotto and he is a bigger star than Cotto. Cotto is the one that needs revenge. Pac is not afraid of the guy he KOed but his team won't let him fight Cotto at 154 and give up 15 or more pounds when they step in the ring. It's unreasonable to expect Pac to do that. Does anyone expect Dawson to give Adamek a chance to avenge his defeat at heavyweight? So Cotto fans and Mayweather fans and Pac haters just declare Cotto the automatic winner of a rematch with Pac at 154 and get it over with because that fight ain't happening.

[Reloaded]

The question was which Cotto was better but all the written answers seem to be about could Cotto beat Pac at 154. I did not see the fight so I did not vote. I think people should realize that Cotto vs Pac at 154 is probably just a fantasy fight that will never happen. If Cotto has developed into a full sized junior middleweight that's great for him and he should stay at that weight. But Pacquiao is the same little guy he always was. He has not grown any bigger at age 33. He is still a big lightweight who weighs in at 144 or 145 after breakfast and lunch and fully hydrated. He already holds a KO win over Cotto and he is a bigger star than Cotto. Cotto is the one that needs revenge. Pac is not afraid of the guy he KOed but his team won't let him fight Cotto at 154 and give up 15 or more pounds when they step in the ring. It's unreasonable to expect Pac to do that. Does anyone expect Dawson to give Adamek a chance to avenge his defeat at heavyweight? So Cotto fans and Mayweather fans and Pac haters just declare Cotto the automatic winner of a rematch with Pac at 154 and get it over with because that fight ain't happening.

You think its more reasonable to have Cotto drained , he was 10 pounds lighter than tonight , that is not quite a reasonable handicap to fight against an A grade fighter in a weakened state , if you want to boast about beating bigger guys dont handicap them to do it .

Oscar Cotto and Margo all beat Pac without a draining CW , Floyd has fought 2 of then now at 154 and both looked a mile better at the weight in terms of speed power resistance and stamina than the CW versions .

Take away draining and he struggles with JMM but can dominate Oscar , come on its obvious the CWs are killing these guys !

[Bushbaby]

Last nights Cotto beats Pacman at a fair weight.

[GoogleMe]

WEll Pacquiao wouldn't fight Cotto at 154.

[MindBat]

wish some of you would get a clue, cotto got owned by pressure fighters that push and work him

floyd fights at a slow pace, had floyd fought a fight as active as the others he probabley would ko cotto earlier than the others

Thank you. Many still refuse to get a clue.

[Reloaded]

Thank you. Many still refuse to get a clue.

Manny cannot fight these guys without weakening them first with a CW , he DUCKED this version , it dont take much of a clue to see why , Manny could not hurt this Cotto and this Cotto doesnt tire badly mid fight , it makes a world of difference to how the fight unfolds , it all looks good when he is drained and on the end of a beating its like fighting with the flu , its a different story when he is as strong as a bull with speed resistance and stamina .

[Ray*]

I think we all dismiss a Cotto rematch with Pacquiao too early by siting the style makes fight argument, But a healthy non-drain Cotto might think he would fare better than he did in 2009.

[bojangles1987]

This site, I swear, lol.

Cotto was in no way better. At all. Difference was Pac kept throwing and hitting, whereas Floyd didn't.