So, im gonna be the one to ask, Cotto tonight vs Cotto from Pac fight....

[mikemurni]

You dont know what your talking about , weight is extremely important especially when your drained below your weight , look at Cotto tonight with a top trainer strong as a bull and no stamina issues , its the best shape he has ever been in , where is 10 pound coming from lol , you would need to chop his arm off to make 145 , he was drained at 145 and thats why Pac will NOT fight him at 154 , he would steam roll Pac , drained or not makes a huge difference .

I am just following your logic here.. I mean JMM was a flabby out of weight WW when he fought Floyd, and Hatton was the lineal LWW when Pac fought him so which means that Pac fought those 2 guys at their best weight.. So we can say that Pac's win was better against those two if we follow your ****** chain of thought...

And if we are at this subject of Hatton as Floyd's leftover..Then Cotto is Pac's leftover.. Except that Pac looked more impressive from both fights..

[boxingfeind]

I am just following your logic here.. I mean JMM was a flabby out of weight WW when he fought Floyd, and Hatton was the lineal LWW when Pac fought him so which means that Pac fought those 2 guys at their best weight.. So we can say that Pac's win was better against those two if we follow your ****** chain of thought...

And if we are at this subject of Hatton as Floyd's leftover..Then Cotto is Pac's leftover.. Except that Pac looked more impressive from both fights..

Marquez had just about the same speed in the Floyd fight as when he fought Pac-r-o-i-d-s.

And Hatton also came in light for his fight with Floyd at welterweight at the weigh in he weighed 145 and he did not look any slower then when he fought at 140 and he started his career at a higher weight class then Floyd.

Being weight drained is worst then moving up in weight cause moving up in weight does`nt make you weaker,it sometimes makes you stronger cause you don`t have lose as much weight when you are making weight.

[mikemurni]

Marquez had just about the same speed in the Floyd fight as when he fought Pac-r-o-i-d-s.

And Hatton also came in light for his fight with Floyd at welterweight at the weigh in he weighed 145 and he did not look any slower then when he fought at 140 and he started his career at a higher weight class then Floyd.

Being weight drained is worst then moving up in weight cause moving up in weight does`nt make you weaker,it sometimes makes you stronger cause you don`t have lose as much weight when you are making weight.

How about punch resistance.. How about being slower, sluggish when adding more weight.. How about the fact that your timing, instincts become a tad slower when you move up..How about the fact that your punches may not be as effective landing at the higher weights..Hmmm...

And since you brought up that topic... Pac was actually moving down on weight when he fought Hatton.. so if we follow that logic of yours then Pac was in a disadvantage when he fought Hatton...So which makes that a better win than Floyd's..

In my point of view is not about weight.. Pac is just a better fighter than Cotto, and there was nothing Cotto could have done in that fight.. Pac's style was just fit to Cotto's style.. And its not like the weight was the cause of his lose.. The same goes for Mosley, and Hatton..

And lol on JMM being not slow when he fought May...

[mikemurni]

Bunch of weight watchers here.. lol.. You guys should just watch the Biggest losers instead of boxing..

[Daddy T]

cotto was better v floyd but even so i don't think pac is a good fight for him even at 154 tbh

[S H A R K B O Y]

This poll must be devastating .

[al-Xander]

Because he wasn't getting hit with 100 punches per round. I've always said that stylistically cotto would give floyd problems. Cotto was just being cotto, using his jab and pinning floyd in the ropes and tee off.

The reason cotto looked good tonight is because he was able to fight at his pace, he was not being pressured and forced to fight.

Good observation. Cotto was even able to use his bike and still can land punches just like in the Margarito fight. In the Pac fight, he just used it to survive and get away from Pac.

[Reloaded]

Bunch of weight watchers here.. lol.. You guys should just watch the Biggest losers instead of boxing..

Pac is the biggest weight watcher in the sport lol , if you dont agree to his special weight clauses he runs away , this 154 Cotto would run over him thats why Pac ducked him at this weight , your an idiot to argue weight and Manny in the same breath , your spin doesnt change the facts that Manny is a WW hype job that manipulates fights to handicap his opponent the smell of a fair fight frightens him , Floyd will school him so easy your ass will be squeaking !

[Reloaded]

Good observation. Cotto was even able to use his bike and still can land punches just like in the Margarito fight. In the Pac fight, he just used it to survive and get away from Pac.

Because he is drained you idiot lol , his resistance is not the same , his strength speed and reaction is not the same , draining effects everything !

This 154 Cotto is a beast not the 145 bonehead looking for a fox hole after the 6th round .

[boxingfeind]

How about punch resistance.. How about being slower, sluggish when adding more weight.. How about the fact that your timing, instincts become a tad slower when you move up..How about the fact that your punches may not be as effective landing at the higher weights..Hmmm...

And since you brought up that topic... Pac was actually moving down on weight when he fought Hatton.. so if we follow that logic of yours then Pac was in a disadvantage when he fought Hatton...So which makes that a better win than Floyd's..

In my point of view is not about weight.. Pac is just a better fighter than Cotto, and there was nothing Cotto could have done in that fight.. Pac's style was just fit to Cotto's style.. And its not like the weight was the cause of his lose.. The same goes for Mosley, and Hatton..

And lol on JMM being not slow when he fought May...

Yeah but Hatton did not lose any speed when he fought Floyd and him coming in heavier benefits him more then Floyd cause Floyd started his career at a lower weight and is not as accustomed to getting hit at higher weight classes then Hatton.And Pacquiao could make 140 easy which is why he went down to fight Hatton.Cotto on the other hand could not make 145 without it draining him which is why he hesitated at first but was forced to come down.

If Pac is a better fighter then Cotto as you say then he should`nt have had any problems at fighting him at 150.He fought Margarito at 150 and Margarito come in at a higher weight on fight night then Cotto.Pacquiao knows that Cotto is a much smarter fighter then Margarito that`s why he wants to drain Cotto.