Calzaghe is seriously overrated

[D4thincarnation]

Unbeaten Jermain Taylor also turned down his biggest pay day to fight Joe, I wonder why?

[TRAV1$]

I could only see "Calzaghe is seriously...", I actually thought this was going to be the first "underrated" thread ever made.

[1g5a22]

calzaghe:

'not only do i beat black fighters, like kosty tszyu i look good doing it'

done deal.

[IronDanHamza]

He is pretty overrated by a lot.

The idea of him being an ATG is laughable IMO.

[IMDAZED]

He is pretty overrated by a lot.

The idea of him being an ATG is laughable IMO.

There was a time on these boards when people were seriously parroting that. SMH.

[D4thincarnation]

He is pretty overrated by a lot.

The idea of him being an ATG is laughable IMO.

Sugar Ray insists: Calzaghe is one of the greats

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/oth...he-greats.html

And this was before he unified the division against Kessler and beat Hopkins.

Calzaghe is an ATG, the greatest Super Middle there ever was.

[Snake...]

calzaghe:

'not only do i beat black fighters, like kosty tszyu i look good doing it'

done deal.

he said that?

[A.P]

I like joe he was good 4 boxing but I dnt think he can beat a prime Roy jones or a prime B-Hop IMO

[komodo]

I like joe he was good 4 boxing but I dnt think he can beat a prime Roy jones or a prime B-Hop IMO

Are you saying a shot to 5hit Hopkins nearly beat Calzaghe, then went on to beat a prime Pavlik and the lineal champ at LHW in Pascal?

[D4thincarnation]

Are you saying a shot to 5hit Hopkins nearly beat Calzaghe, then went on to beat a prime Pavlik and the lineal champ at LHW in Pascal?

Lets not forget beating Winky and schooling Tarver just before, as well as 4/5 years later just dropping a decision to Dawson.


Too bad Hopkins pulled out of a chance to fight Calzaghe back in 2003