Prime 147 Shane Vs Prime 147 Floyd

[turbotime]

I can't believe people think he would beat Floyd if they both were in their primes. Shane had too many flaws that he could never ever fix. Look at both fights vs Winky Wright and you will quickly get your answer right there. Shane is good but he relies too much on his speed and power and not enough skill to win. This is exactly why Winky beat him as easily as he did.

Wright barely won the rematch.

[4Corners]

I can't believe people think he would beat Floyd if they both were in their primes. Shane had too many flaws that he could never ever fix. Look at both fights vs Winky Wright and you will quickly get your answer right there. Shane is good but he relies too much on his speed and power and not enough skill to win. This is exactly why Winky beat him as easily as he did.

Don't argue Winky Wright with Turbo. He HATES Winky Wright. Winky didn't beat him "easily" though in the rematch.

[turbotime]

No. But Floyd beating Castillo and Sosa is far superior to Shane was beating Holiday, Leija, and Molina. Castillo alone is superior Shane beating those 3.

H2H, it's a good fight, I'm rolling with Floyd on that one. It's all opinions. But Floyd did more at 135 by just beating Jose Luis Castillo, the best LW of his era. That's all I'm saying. And all I mentioned about Sosa was that win is equal to Leija or Molina when Shane beat them. That's all.

Sosa isn't as good as Molina and Leija. just my opinion.

[IronDanHamza]

No. But Floyd beating Castillo and Sosa is far superior to Shane was beating Holiday, Leija, and Molina. Castillo alone is superior Shane beating those 3.

H2H, it's a good fight, I'm rolling with Floyd on that one. It's all opinions. But Floyd did more at 135 by just beating Jose Luis Castillo, the best LW of his era. That's all I'm saying. And all I mentioned about Sosa was that win is equal to Leija or Molina when Shane beat them. That's all.

Either way, styles make fights.

Mosley hasn't and never will beat anyone with the jab, skills or ability of Mayweather.

The only reason he beat Oscar the first time was because Oscar decided to be Macho Man instead of Oscar.

The second fight Oscar outboxed him with ease I thought.

[IronDanHamza]

Sosa isn't as good as Molina and Leija. just my opinion.

He's as good if not better than the versions Shane fought.

Not that that's saying much.

[turbotime]

Don't argue Winky Wright with Turbo. He HATES Winky Wright. Winky didn't beat him "easily" though in the rematch.

I don't hate Wright. I just dislike him

[turbotime]

He's as good if not better than the versions Shane fought.

Not that that's saying much.

Just...no.

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

I'd pick Floyd. Shane was good, but Floyd's defense is the main difference.

[IronDanHamza]

Just...no.

Why?

The one's Oscar fought are better, absolutely.

The irrelelvant, washed up ones Shane fought were about as good, if not worse.

[turbotime]

Why?

The one's Oscar fought are better, absolutely.

The irrelelvant, washed up ones Shane fought were about as good, if not worse.

Maybe because Sosa never did anything before, or after?